As a junior engineer in the Department of Water Supply for the past five years, my responsibilities included ensuring water quality and maintaining supply lines for regular distribution. The zone I was posted in had persistent water shortage issues, particularly exacerbated during the summer when the supply became erratic. Residents had to rely heavily on water tankers, which added to their financial burden and inconvenience. Over the years, I observed that the disruptions in water supply were not merely due to technical issues or natural scarcity. Through careful monitoring and data collection, I uncovered evidence suggesting that a cartel of tanker owners was deliberately creating an artificial shortage. This cartel would tamper with the water supply lines, causing disruptions, and then capitalise on the situation by selling water at inflated prices. The activities of this cartel were not only illegal but also highly unethical, exploiting the residents' basic need for water. With substantial evidence in hand, I decided to take action against the cartel. I met with the district Superintendent of Police (SP) and presented my findings. The SP appeared concerned and promised to initiate action against the culprits. However, two weeks passed without any noticeable action being taken. Frustrated and determined, I scheduled another meeting with the SP to understand the delay. During our meeting, the SP candidly explained the situation. He acknowledged the problem and the validity of my evidence but expressed his inability to act due to the cartel's strong political connections and influence. He feared for the safety of his men and the potential repercussions on his career if he went against such powerful interests. This revelation left me in a difficult position, as I understood the SP's predicament but also felt a deep responsibility to address the issue for the sake of the community. (a) What are the options available to you in the above situation? (b) What will be your chosen course of action? (c) Identify the ethical issues involved in the case (d) Suggest some measures for handling cartels who prey on people's needs.
Divyank Gupta, AIR 21, 2024
(a) Options available to me
1. Leak the information to the media about inaction on part of SP 2. Let go of the situation as it's difficult to fight the system 3. Talk to the SP about moral courage. If he is not interested then reach out to DM of district or DM at higher level for justice
(b) Chosen course of action
1. First I will try to persuade SP to show courage of conviction as W.E.B. Du Bois said - "It's better to stand in the mud than to lick boots" 2. If he is not convinced then reach out to DM for action 3. If DM not ready then raise this issue internally in department of water supply and contact the Secretary of department 4. If no action is taken then leak the information to the media as a whistleblower
Justification 1. Inaction is equal to cowardice 2. Charles de Gaulle said that time of cowardice calls for individual heroic action 3. As a public servant in government dept, my duty is to serve people
(c) Ethical Issue involved
1. Cartel of Tanker Owners - doing unethical and illegal work - taking away rights of people to live well - responsible for thousands of deaths due to consumption of contaminated water and water shortage - moral turpitude 2. SP - lacks moral courage to act - puts his personal privilege over public service 3. Department of Water Supply - not tackling the issue of water shortage and cartel formation - lack of devotion to duty 4. Residents of District - suffer from standard justice - natural and inalienable rights are taken away
(d) Measures for Handling Cartels
1. Transparent bidding - to ensure new contractors come in 2. Monitoring of pipeline through CCTV cameras to ensure no leakage of water to these cartels 3. Severe punishment when someone found guilty 4. State department to be prepared beforehand for excess supply 5. Measures like City of Lakes project of Delhi government to increase water supply
This case study needs moral enlightenment and devotion to do tough thing when called upon.