Topper Copies

As the Superintendent of Police (SP) in a peaceful district, I was accustomed to handling minor crimes such as petty thefts, property encroachments, and small fights. The crime rate was low, and the people generally kept to their business, making it a relatively easy workplace. However, over the past month, my office began receiving a different kind of grievance that indicated a more complex issue brewing in the community. A significant number of complaints were received from villagers who reported losing money from their bank accounts without their knowledge. These grievances were alarming, especially since they came from a demographic that was largely illiterate and unfamiliar with modern banking practices. The villagers were confused and distraught, not understanding how their hard-earned money was disappearing. Upon conducting a preliminary enquiry, we discovered that the money was not exactly being stolen but was being deducted as insurance premiums for policies under the State Government's Bima Yojna. The villagers were unaware that they had even signed up for such policies, raising suspicions about the legitimacy of these transactions. A deeper investigation revealed that agents from government banks were aggressively pushing the Bima Yojna. These agents had been instructed to meet government targets for the scheme, leading them to add beneficiaries without proper consent. Most of the villagers were illiterate and had no understanding of the insurance policies they were enrolled in. The deductions were legal, but the methods used to obtain the villagers' consent were highly questionable. You were wondering about the course of action, as the deductions were legal, and the agents were technically following instructions. But, in the process, they were exploiting the poor villagers. (a) What are the ethical issues involved in the above case? (b) What are the options available to you as an SP? (c) Explain your chosen course of an action. (d) If you have to recommend a better way of promoting the bima yojna, what would that be?

Divyank Gupta, AIR 21, 2024

The case study is about the classic case of legal vs ethical which leads to ethical dilemma and harm to the weakest.

(a) Stakeholder / Ethical issues

1. Agents of Insurance - Bima Yojana - following unethical ways to get more clients - in line with Herbert Marcuse's One Dimensional Man - lack of compassion and empathy for the poor and illiterate villagers 2. State Government - lack of right ways to meet policies - against DPSP of state taking measures for welfare of people - violation of policies made by following veil of ignorance (John Rawls) 3. Villagers - suffering from plight of state policies - lack of education and lack of participatory governance 4. Me (SP) - follows state laws vs conscience - dilemma between my role in implementing vs compassion for villagers

(b) Options available to Me

1. Let the scheme continue the way it is, since it is legal 2. Makes the state government aware of the issues and ask support from local representative to build confidence 3. Ask villagers to go to court and challenge the state government and Bima company

(c) My chosen course of Action

1. I will choose option 2 2. I will inform the state government about the breach of trust 3. A committee should be formed to ensure peace building and bridging the trust deficit 4. Use of persuasion to inform the villagers about how insurance will help them later 5. If some villagers don't want insurance, then their money should be paid back 6. Action against the agents since they followed unethical practices 7. Their licence should be cancelled 8. Apologise to the villagers from the insurance company for unethical act

Justification - It would ensure justice and fairness in the system - would ensure good governance turns into ethical governance - in line with the constitution where preamble says, state derives power from people - would uphold Kant's deontology and Rawlsian justice

(d) Better way of Promoting Bima Yojana

1. Participatory and consensus building procedure should be followed 2. They should be made aware about benefits and all the policies' facts 3. Grievance redressal and citizen charter method on line of Ahmedabad model to be followed

This would ensure that ethical governance which our Constitutional Makers wanted prevails.