You recently took over as CEO of Beta Technologies, a renowned IT services and consulting firm in India established in 1990. Over the past three decades, the company has grown into a global player with clients in North America, Europe, and Asia. Known for cutting-edge solutions and strong client relationships, Beta Technologies has been a market leader in the IT sector. It has been three weeks since you took over, and one day, the company's legal head came to you with a report that they had discovered discrepancies in the company's financial statement. For five years, the company's financial officer (CFO), Mr. Rahul Mehta, has manipulated its earnings reports. By inflating revenues and understating expenses, he has created a false image of financial health to boost stock prices and secure more investment. Further, it was found that Mr. Mehta has significant personal investments in some of the company's vendors. These vendors were awarded lucrative contracts, often at inflated prices and with favourable terms detrimental to the company. Mr Mehta's actions have compromised the procurement process and led to financial losses for the company. As CEO, you were confronted with a critical decision. You also had to contend with financial irregularities and a skewed procurement process. As a new CEO: (a) What decision options are available to you? (b) What are the issues involved in the above case? (c) What will be your chosen course of action and Why?
Divyank Gupta, AIR 21, 2024
The given case reflected the personal gain which people favour at the cost of the organisation and society which they are working.
Facts: - Violation of corporate governance rules - Against company's commitment to higher values - Sort of internal trading - Stock manipulation - Financial irregularities
(a) Decision options available to Me
1. Let go of the issue because if news comes out, it would harm the image of the company and its client base 2. Directly oust Mr. Mehta for fraud and manipulation, thereby leading to financial irregularities 3. Inform the Board of Directors of the firm, set up an internal committee to look into the issue and then take decision
(b) Issues involved in the above Case
1. Mr Rahul Mehta - - lack of integrity - violation of professional ethics - harm to public interest - putting company's image at risk 2. Company's vendors in whom Rahul Mehta has invested - conflict of interest - lack of probity in their business - collusive corruption 3. Companies - too much discretionary power in one person leading to misuse of power - lack of effective checks and balances for early disclosure of irregularities 4. Me - time to show courage of conviction - ethical dilemma between company's image vs moral wrongness
(c) Chosen Course of action
1. I will choose option 2 and 3 2. First I will inform the board of governors about the irregularities faced 3. Set up an internal committee consisting of independent directors for fair report 4. On the basis of report, all people who are involved, action will be taken against them 5. Then tenders of those who got it at inflated price would be cancelled 6. New bid for tenders at fair price would be done 7. Systemic reforms to ensure not too much discretionary power in one person 8. Making it clear to all employees to not invest in client's business due to conflict of interest
Justification
This would ensure that the wrongs done are made right. It would bring confidence among employees and clients that the company follows business ethics. It would be in line with what Krishna says - Dharma Rakshati Rakshitah - if you protect dharma, dharma will protect you.