Competition is the law of the jungle, but cooperation is the law of civilization.
Divyank Gupta, AIR 21, 2024
Competition is the law of the jungle, but cooperation is the law of civilisation
"In this difficult day, in this difficult time for the United States, it is perhaps well to ask what kind of a nation we are and what direction we want to move in. For those of you who are black, considering the evidence, you can be filled with resentment that it was white who are responsible and try to avenge them. Or we can make an effort, as Martin Luther King did, to understand, to comprehend and to replace that violence with an effort to understand with companion and love. What we need in USA is not division; what we need in USA is not hatred but love and companion towards one another."
This speech was made by Robert Kennedy in Indianapolis on the day Martin Luther King was assassinated. In this speech, Robert Kennedy is emphasising that if Blacks and whites compete against each other, it would lead to collapse of the country but by having compassion and understanding each other, USA could reach great heights. In essence, he is saying that competition is the law of the jungle but cooperation is the law of the civilisation.
Before we move ahead, we need to ask ourselves, what does Jungle symbolises? Jungle symbolises a region which has no law and Order, where justice does not prevail, where there is might of the strongest and weakest are at the mercy of them.
Then it is obvious to ask what does civilization means or what does it represent? Civilisation here represents an era where justice, law and order exists. There is prosperity and peace in the region. There is virtue in people and society.
Having seen the meaning of Jungle and civilisation, it is we need to ask why competition is the law of Jungle? Competition is a symbol of rat race where people simply are chasing their dreams without a thought of other. They see others not as a threat and enemy rather fellow human beings.
This rat race is called by Osho in his book "Awareness" as human becoming rats since all the tests which are done by scientists on a rat are hold to be true for humans as well. This rat race pits one man against another and therefore leads to fight over resources.
This fight could be seen from the fight over competitive exams where over million students compete for 1000 seats and many of those who fail commit suicide. It could be seen from fight over global resources like oil which happened in 1990s and 2000s or in the current time happening in Russia.
All these fights and competition lead to absence of law and order and puts the most vulnerable at risk which could be seen from plead of people from Rafah for help.
On the other hand, when people cooperate, it brings the best of everyone together and leads to holistic development. It could be seen from the highest growth recorded by world in the first decade of 21st century after formation of WTO in 1995 & Uruguay Round. WTO enabled lower tariffs and gave opportunities to countries to specialise in their domain and reduce the logistics cost and cost of production and thereby more growth.
Moreover when people cooperate, a mass action can be taken even against the toughest of the toughest problem. The success of the Montreal protocol is a case in point. With the support of the global community, Montreal protocol lead to the end of ozone hole and showed what we can achieve by working together.
Further, cooperation ensures that countries can take actions for reforms and usher into an era of peace which is an important tenet of civilisation. This could be seen from the Yuval Harari Book of Homo Deus which says that due to cooperation and international treaty, world has seen significant reduction in violence. From 15% of deaths by violence to 1% from 19th to 21st century shows that cooperation leads to civilisation.
Apart from this, cooperation among the people and countries ensure that universal values prevail in the society. These values are compassion, empathy, love, wisdom which Robert Kennedy talked about in his speech, are necessary for surviving and thriving of any society.
Why is it then that people compete rather than cooperating? One of the reason is that people still believe and live in an era where they feel that there will be shortage of resource and so they should hoard as much as they can. However, this is not true as Max Tegmark in his book Life 3.0 said that - with the revolution in technology fields, world would enter a "phase of Post Plenitude" where there won't be crisis of resources and therefore happiness of people won't depend on hoarding wealth and Resources but on whether they can find a meaning and purpose in their life.
Secondly, the society is built in a way where set parameters have been defined for success. Those who are able to tick all that criteria are regarded as winners and remaining as failure. Therefore, we need to change this approach of judging people on fixed criteria as humans are blessed with multiple level of intelligence. Thereby we need to follow what Einstein said - "If you judge the success of a fish by its ability to climb a tree, it will always be regarded as failure."
Thirdly, people often forget that they are mortal and that is why they tend to compete their whole lives. In this scenario it becomes important to remember and follow what Shakespeare said - "Every third thought should be my grave." Because the thought that we are mortal, leads us to focus on things that actually matter for humanity.
Now, we have seen how cooperation leads to civilisation and competition ends it. But it is pertinent to ask is competition all bad? Is there no use of competition in civilisation? The answer is no. As History is filled with examples where civilisations have collapsed because they got complacent and couldn't change with changing times. These rulers and people stopped working and reforming. Or in the words of Shakespeare "Plenty and Peace breeds cowards."
Therefore, competition is necessary. As the economic survey of 2019-20 pointed out that due to digitisation, liberalisation, the average age of a company is coming down. New startups are challenging the old companies hegemony and bringing in economic democracy, thereby strengthening civilisation.
Similarly, Amartya Sen in his book "The Argumentative Indian" says that India witnessed very less famine after Independence because India became democratic. The presence of competition within Indian politics led the government to ensure that no famine like situation arises. Therefore, this competition actually led to civilisation by working towards the weakest and ensuring equity.
In today's time, the world is facing new challenges in the form of competition over access to territory of other country, over global commons. In this scenario we need to separate the good competition from the bad and ensure that competition should be used to advance the civilisation and not end it.
Reflecting back on the speech of Robert F Kennedy, we need to learn more from one of his quotes
"Some men see things as they are and say why. I dream things that never were and say why not."
Let us all take inspiration from this to dream and create a world where there is cooperation for everything, where justice prevails and where rights of the weak are considered to be equally important as that of strong.