Topper Copies

Despite the criticism against it, the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act continues to have utility. Critically examine.

Shakti Dubey, AIR 1, 2024

Armed forces special powers Act was enacted in 1956 to tackle the problem of North east insurgency, further extended to Jammu & Kashmir

AFSPA :- It provides unlimited powers to the Armed forces to ensure stability in the disturbed area: 1. 2nd ARC report has recommended for its abolition which was also supplemented by MHA report 2. It has been criticised for the human right violation 3. It does not provide for Investigation into excesses committed by Armed forces

However it's utility cannot be overlooked :- 1. Because India faces Internal security threat like: NE insurgency, extremism in J&K, Naxalism, etc 2. It is surrounded by hostile neighbours which fuel the National security challenges 3. These can act as a threat to India's sovereignity and territorial integrity.

Despite the importance of the Act there is a need for - proper & controlled application of law -> ensures proportionality of the law - In any case human rights must be kept at the heart

Recently several areas from Manipur has been excluded from Ambit of AFSPA & it's a right step towards democratisation of laws