What ethical dilemmas arise from the use of economic sanctions in international relations, and how can policymakers balance these concerns with the need to punish illegal behaviours and compel political change?
Divyank Gupta, AIR 21, 2024
The recent economic sanctions on Russia after the Russia-Ukraine war have brought in light the ethical dilemmas in sanction.
Ethical dilemmas in Sanctions
1. Punishing the leader or the country - eg Russia is autocrat and decision made by only top leadership 2. Gandhiji said that hate the sins but not the sinner 3. Current geopolitical situation is a result of west increasing NATO influence 4. Sanctions have done only more harm to people and country
Policymakers can balance 2 concerns by
1. Undertaking reforms like UNSC reform for wider stakeholder consultation 2. Preventing antagonisation of the countries through immoral act 3. Following dialogue and diplomacy as said by PM Modi 4. Follow Integral Humanism approach of Deendayal Upadhyaya in IR
As the quote goes, "Only the dead have seen an end of war." It must be followed and lived by.