Topper Copies

"The motive has nothing to do with the morality of the action." In light of the above statement, do you think motive is irrelevant in determining the morality of an action? Explain your position with relevant examples.

Divyank Gupta, AIR 21, 2024

There has been everlasting debate between morality and motive between people due to different forms of ethics.

Motive is irrelevant in determining Morality

1. Morality is determined by one's action (Kant's deontology) 2. Gandhiji said that right means will take care of the motive itself 3. Keeping morality motive in mind leads to wrong action - eg Yudhishtra's lack of integrity when he said Ashwathama is dead 4. Shifting focus from morality to motive leads one to legitimise all action - eg USA justified dropping nuclear bomb on Japan

However Motive Sometimes become important

1. During national security, things like spying, ethical hacking are needed 2. Krishna said in Mahabharata that if adharma can be stopped by one non-truthful action, then also it establishes dharma 3. Greater good theory under Utilitarianism says the same

Therefore need is to follow that morality takes precedence and until under very important for greater good, it should be avoid. We must remember that even Yudishthar (Dharmaraj) had to go to hell for the lie he spoke.