Topper Copies

Quality of public service delivery is a major determinant of the quality of life of vulnerable sections in a highly unequal society divided along the lines of class, caste, religion, etc. In this background, do you think that public service delivery is efficient and sufficient enough to improve the lives of vulnerable groups in India? Critically examine.

Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023

Gandhiji's Talisman can be used to understand the case of public service delivery & judge its effectiveness if it has been able to uplift the poorest of the poor.

Public service delivery is not efficient & sufficient enough ->

1. Focuses on Means - Js Mill's utilitarianism ethics is not followed where goals are not at the core of the public delivery but rules are.

2. lack of last mile delivery - 16% of Indians are multidimensionally poor, necessitating to fill the gap.

3. lack of right beneficiary selection - Ex 22% of ration cards in chattisgarh found to be bogus.

4. lack of social audits and community participation has led to eroding of transparency & accountability.

5. Culture & tradition like caste system, gender discrimination, religious bias hinders in effectiveness, ex Dalit children in separate row for midday meal.

But the public service delivery has achievements -> - Reduction in infant & child mortality rate to 98/lakh & 27/1000 respectively - 67% of Indians under PDS - schemes like MGNREGA has reduced rural poverty - urban poverty is on decline with schemes like SVANIDHI, NULM etc. - Tribals integrated to mainstream (PM Van Dhan, Eklavya)

As Atal Bihari Bajpayee notes the success of government is not in economic growth but in effective governance & public service delivery.