Topper Copies

The introduction of Goods and Services Tax (GST) was hailed as a transformative fiscal reform; however, the journey of GST has been a mixed bag of successes and challenges. Analyse.

Vibhor Bhardwaj, AIR 19, 2024

Goods and Services Act was introduced with 101st constitutional amendment Act.

GST: A transformative fiscal reform

1. Unified tax structure throughout the country 2. Elimination of cascading tax structure at multiple points. 3. Different slabs ensuring a dual playing -> for sin goods 28% to deter their use. 4. Increasing formalization with registration of GST portal. 5. More voice to states in GST council with 2/3rd weightage to states. 6. Enhanced revenue collection from GST with record collection last year. 7. Enhanced coverage of tax with widening tax items. 8. Revenue compensation to states for GST.

CHALLENGES

1. Revenue loss to states: 52% while for centre only 20%, leading to asymmetric fiscal burden 2. Various tax rates even on varying products. 3. Petroleum products still out of GST. 4. Initial implementation took MSME at their worst and combined with Demonetization many went out of business. 5. Informal MSME sector could not access GST infrastructure. 6. The GST Tax Buoyancy has not been great but of mixed outcomes.

Hence GST needs can appellate as well as consultative approach in further better implementation.