Topper Copies

"In a fluid geopolitical arena, engagement without formal endorsement is a pragmatic middle path." Do you agree? Explain in the context of India's current approach towards the Taliban regime in Afghanistan.

Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025

World is going through a phase of constant flux, with rapidly changing geopolitical arena. eg US under Trump, EU's rise of right, chinese agression etc.

Why formal endorsements not preferred a. Complicates partnership -> as world powers intervene eg India Afghan under wraps b. Complexities involved eg Taliban a terror org c. Global image & reputation at stake -> thus need of covert diplomacy d. Rigidities in engagements

Engagement without endorsement 1. Ensure diplomatic ties are maintained eg India afghan shares deep ties

[diagram: rough map showing Afghanistan, China, Pakistan and India]

2. Maintain continuity in relations eg People & People ties in Afghan 3. Protect mutual interest eg Counter Pak's terror propoganda. 4. Ensure synergy on existing arenas of cooperation a. Economic - India-Afghan trade ties + Indian investment in Afghan (20C-$10bn) b. Political - SAARC, Central Asia & Iran connect c. Projects such as building of Salma Dam & Parliament etc by India 5. Gives diplomatic headstart -> eg China-Russia-Pak already engaging 6. Prevent black box syndrome -> maintain communication b/w nations 7. Issue based partnership with flexibility

Concerns a. Continued human rights violation by Taliban in Afg b. Against idealistic principles of India eg Democracy c. Terror sponsorship -> J&K militancy d. Pak's leverage in Afg hamper India-Afg ties

Way ahead a. Can deepen partnership eg Mutual cooperation b. P2P ties strengthen.