Topper Copies

Discuss how gender-based violence in India is a manifestation of patriarchal values. To what extent has modernisation in law served as an instrument of women's empowerment in this regard?

Madhav Agarwal, AIR 16, 2024

Patriarchy is a hideous feature of Indian society driven by domination by men over women. This often fuels gender based violence:

Gender violence as manifestation of patriarchy 1. Rape cases: are fueled by the belief of gullibility of women, seen as soft-target. 2. Domestic violence: cases are on rise as per NCRB showing signs of women oppression by in-laws. 3. Marital rape & violence: as per NFHS-5, 1/3rd women experienced sexual/mental abuse -> driven by "doctrine of coverture" (women as property). 4. Sexual harassment at workplace: faced by female employees due to lack of acceptance of women in office. 5. Physical expression of old age: by sending the widows to Vrindavan/old age homes. 6. Female foeticide: driven by "son meta-preference", women safety attached to pride of family. 7. Lack of reporting of gender crimes due to confidential/secrecy culture.

Role of law in empowerment Positive role 1. Strict punishment: capital punishment for rape & murder. 2. Evolving role: Vishakha guidelines brought to reform criminal system. 3. Fast track courts brought by states 4. Diverse laws: to bring attitudinal change for dowry, domestic violence, POSH Act, etc.

Shortfalls 1. Crimes continue unabated: eg: Dowry prevails. 2. Poor conviction rate due to delayed investigation 3. Low reporting of crimes due to fear of stigma. 4. Laws itself unjust: eg: Marital rape. 5. Poor representation of women in police/judges.

We need to understand law is not an end, "JUSTICE IS THE END". We need realisation focused justice as called by Amartya Sen.