Topper Copies

Not everything that can be counted counts, and not everything that counts can be counted.

Divyank Gupta, AIR 21, 2024

Whole India was shocked when the news of Sucide of V.G. Siddhartha spred. V.G. Siddhartha, also known as Coffee King of India was known for business tactics and was a well known face of the story of - "from rage to riches".

When he died, his net worth was over $1.5 billion. People were finding it hard to believe that how can a person so rich, so successful commit suicide? But the news after his death revealed that he was facing severe market pressure and was dealing with mental health issue.

This case of V.G. Siddhartha is not the only case where people focus on the some of the external benchmarks they have set for others and judge their life on that basis. They forget that there are many things which can't be measured and the fact that an individual, a society, a nation on the whole would is not just composed of simple facts but many things which can't be counted but they do have their impact and a critical one Indeed.

Therefore, it is important to differentiate things that can be counted and things which can't be counted but still matter. Things which can be counted are money, wealth of a person, GDP of a country, Labour force participation of a workfore, pace of growth of any technology. On the other hande there are things which cannot be counted but still counts. Things are like mental health, happiness of an individual or society, social capital in society, character of individuals in society. These things are hard to measure but they play a very important role in life of an individual.

Having seen what are the things that can be counted and what can't, it is we shall explore various perspective in our essay. First we will see why not everything that can be counted counts? Then we will explore why things that counts, cannot be counted? Further, we will see that if things which are counted don't matter much, then should we give up counting? Moving ahead, we will see what are ways to modify and built upon current method of information collection to make it better secure humanity.

We saw in the case of VG Siddhartha that people and reports measured his income, his wealth, his shares but all of that failed at last in preventing him from committing suicide. Taking cue from this, it is pertinent to ask why not everything which can be counted counts? There are multiple reasons for it.

Firstly, the parameters which various indexes and reports use for judging the development of an individual or a country or the world are not the parameters on which life is based on. These are man made parameters. Or in the words of Yuval Noah Harari, they are imaginative reality, i.e. an alternate reality which humans consider to be true. That is why stats keep focusing on money, wealth while ignoring the most fundamental principle of humanity like - cooperation, compassion, justice. Therefore these parameters don't count much.

Secondly, these parameters are often limited in nature and don't show the holistic picture. For example, women LFPR is said to be at 41% in India, but as per various economist, this growth is coming due to disguised unemployment of women in sectors like agriculture, or from informal sectors. Therefore PLFS may count the workfore but it cannot show true picture.

Thirdly, the parameters used in counting are often focused on short term goal and don't focus on long term well being. For example, countries and institutions are obsessed about their GDP growth while forgetting about the rapid rate of depletion of natural resources. They may be growing now but in long term, their survival will be at threat.

Fourthly, leaders and countries often obsesses about the growth only and not how that growth is coming. The example of China is a case in point. In the early 1960s, China under Mao Zedong started the programme of Great Leap Forward where it targetted massive growth. But they resorted to tactics like burning all the steel equipments even the ones used for agriculture to increase their steel production. As a result, the steel production increased but China suffered massive famine where over 45 million people died. Thus what started as Great leap forward became Great leap backward.

Having seen that not everything that can be counted counts, let's move to another dimension, that why thing which count like happiness, social capital etc cannot be counted? There are many reasons for it.

Firstly, it is difficult to come up with pin pointed parameters to measure them. For example, Emotional Intelligence (EI) or Emotional Quotient (EQ) matter a lot as Daniel Goleman said that "it is not IQ which makes you the leader but EQ", but it is difficult to measure it. It is because, it involves human emotions, their values, their attitude. All these factor lead to complexity and therefore make it tough to measure.

Secondly, various ethical values play a very important role for both personal and professional success but there can't be one method to measure it. For instance during the 1961 presidential election both Kennedy and Nixon were having almost same chance of winning with Nixon being few point higher than Kennedy. But one instance changed the fate of both. It was when Martin Luther King was arrested during civil rights movement. Nixon shied away from this as he thought he would antagonize white voters but Kennedy protested against it. As a result of this moral conviction Kennedy won by 1.5% votes. This shows how values like moral conviction play role and counts but we can't measure them pin point.

Having seen that not everything that can be counted counts and not every thing that counts can be asked, it is pertinent to ask that if counting is not doing any good should we drop it all together? No, as the famous saying goes "what gets measured, gets improved", we should try to improve the quality of counting.

For example NITI Aayog took inspiration from model of Multidimensal Poverty Index (MPI) and made it more vibrant by bringing in 12 parameters for calculating poverty rate. As a result, MPI reduced from 24% to 14% in 5 years from FY14 to FY19, thereby highlighting that making a robust method of counting can help.

Moreover, counting leads to quality information and brings in more deliberation and debate. In his book, Argumentative Indian, Amartya Sen says that India didn't face famine of the same level as it did during British Period because India had democracy. This democracy ensured timely data on rainfall, on food availability and accessibility and created pressure on incumbent government to act. Thus counting helped in making Indian democracy a substantive one.

Apart from this, emphasing on counting can help us in getting close to measuring things that matter. For example, Bhutan became the 1st country to measure Happiness through Happiness Index. Although there might be reservation about happiness is different for everybody but this effort of Bhutan led to Global Happiness Index where countries now focus not only meeting the Material needs of their citizens but also about the quality of their life.

Therefore, we have seen that how a right counting method can help. But it is also important to look that how we should go ahead with this? How we can bring in better methodology?

One way is to follow scientific way developed by many scholars. For example the Randomised Control Trial (RCT) methodology of Abhijeet Banerjee and Esther Duflo looks into various parameters that infact a particular outcome and then helps in deciding which parameters we can focus more. Taking inspiration from this could help us in focusing on right things.

Another way, is to bring in multiple stakeholders for diverse inputs. For instance in Rwanda, the performance of civil servants is judged by committee of people. This helps in ensuring not only accountability of Bureaucrats but also ensuring that what matters to citizens, whether it is being delivered or not. In this way, they are able to do things that counts.

Lastly it is also important to focus on ensuring that there is no biasedness in data so that people have trust and are willing to improve and build upon data. This would help a lot in todays world where we are witnessing rising suicide rate, happiness level going down, decline of social capital. Only a right data on things which count can help it. It would prevent instances like V.G. Siddhartha suicide from happening.

It is time to use data for the right purpose for ensuring what Robert Kennedy said - "Some men see the world as it is and ask why, I see things that don't exist and ask why not." Counting things which count would help us in creating a world more just, more fair and more transparent.