Compare and contrast the features of ancient Indian universities like Nalanda and Takshashila with modern state-funded universities in India. What lessons can modern universities learn from ancient ones to improve their effectiveness?
Madhav Agarwal, AIR 16, 2024
The ancient Indian universities had its unique style which attracted travellers from world wide. They even acted as birthplace of famous people like Chanakya, Aryabhatta, etc.
Comparison of features Common elements 1. Both ancient & modern universities get state support. 2. Attraction to students to learn & grow. 3. Pedagogy of teacher & student via classroom followed 4. Act as a "sub-culture" of "pockets" due to inter-mingling of traditions.
Contrasting the features
| | Nalanda & Takshila | Indian Modern universities | |---|---|---| | Course coverage | Indian field of education: astronomy, spirituality, etc. | Focus on the British field of education mainly. | | Infrastructure | Traditional & orthodox setup. | Modern & scientific tools like labs, sports centres. | | Role of Religion | Great role | Religion at back seat as secularism maintained. | | Participation | Open to all, affordable | Open to all, but often expensive. | | Focus on | Learning rather than exams | More exam & degree oriented learning today. |
Lessons that can be learned by modern universities 1. Role of spiritualism & religion to tackle issue of mental health and suicides. 2. Becoming "centres of innovation" rather than rote learning. 3. Attract foreign students more while retaining drain of brain, so that economy develops human resource. 4. Affordability & access must be ensured to all willing & competent. 5. Regionally spread out rather than being concentrated at few urban centres.
While holding our "VIRASAT" we can focus on "VIKAS" as called by Hon. PM Modi during Amrit kaal.