Do you think the Uniform Civil Code contradicts the idea of religious pluralism and cultural differences in Indian society?
Madhav Agarwal, AIR 16, 2024
UCC is a uniform code that ensures common laws on matters of marriage, adoption, inheritance. It is under Article 44 of DPSP.
Yes seen as contradiction 1. Religious differences in marriage customs will be harmonised. 2. Uniformity will prevail rather than diversity 3. Cultural differences will get evened out eg: no polygamy in all religions 4. Fear of threat to secularism and may fuel communalism.
No, not a threat 1. The target is not on religious side but on "secular aspects" like marriage, inheritance. 2. Will also usher women empowerment by reducing patriarchal provisions. 3. Need to driven by discussion & dialogue rather than top-down manner.
Cases like Sarla Mudgal, Shah Bano call for reforms like UCC. Goa is a shining case study. We must respect the pluralism and ensure cordial & gradual implementation.