Inside a busy city administration office, Joint Municipal Commissioner Keerthi, who also serves as the Public Information Officer (PIO), faces a challenging situation. Recently, an RTI application has been received, demanding details about public infrastructure projects initiated during her tenure. Upon reviewing the requested information, Keerthi discovers that certain decisions made regarding these projects were not entirely sound in hindsight. These decisions, although taken in good faith and after due diligence, failed to realize promised outcomes. There were other employees also who were party to this decision. The disclosure of this information could potentially lead to scrutiny and backlash against herself, the employees, and contractors involved. Known for her integrity and commitment to public service, Keerthi finds herself at a crossroads. The RTI Act has served as a critical check against administrative arbitrariness, ensuring transparency and accountability. However, she also observes a troubling trend. RTI applications are often used by vested interests and activists seeking personal gain rather than genuine public interest. Some activists even resort to threats or extortion tactics, undermining the integrity of the RTI process. She fears the requested RTI information could be similarly exploited. Moreover, the employees involved are requesting her to withhold the information. In navigating this situation, Keerthi weighs her options carefully. (a) Critically examine the options available to Keerthi in the above situation. (b) Which of the above would be the most appropriate for Keerthi and why?
Chitwan Jain, AIR 17, 2025
Keerthi is faced with crisis of conscience between own gain and serving justice, can be understood as
3 D's of case
- Duty -> Duty of Keerthi to disclose Information as PIO - Dilemma -> To choose between preserving self interest and colleagues interest v/s upholding Rule of law - Decision -> She is facing two options - 1. To accept whatever punishment she will face if info comes out 2. Hide information and reject RTI request, citing no-existence
a) Options available
1. Release information truly and fulfil duty as PIO
| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | No crisis of conscience | Scrutiny on her as well as colleagues | | Uphold Rule of law and duty | Loss of job and goodwill |
2. Deny information citing vague reasons
| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Safe from scrutiny and punishment | Crisis of conscience | | Ensures growth of career | Truth may come out eventually | | | Backlash of civil society |
3. Consult with senior and find alternate to avert crisis
| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Gain faith of senior and colleagues | No alternate may appear | | Chances of being saved | Discontent and punishment by senior |
c) Choice of option
I will choose to ->
1. Release information without delay to uphold my Fiduciary duty. 2. Not fear any scrutiny as I have done my best. 3. Persuade colleagues to accept the fate to avoid crisis of conscience.
why
1. This will ensure I work for public without selfish interest 2. Upholds Justice and Constitutional Right to information of citizens. 3. "There is no pillow so soft as clear conscience" 4. Do not fear termination, as I am capable enough to find another job 5. As it was honest mistake there would not be any guilt to accept it.
Thus Gandhiji said "Deepest places in hell are reserved for those who remain silent in crisis", I will not be silent and showcase fortitude to accept my mistake and work to correct it in future.