The Siang Upper Multipurpose Project (SUMP) is proposed on a river in a northeastern state of India, a recognized biodiversity hotspot. Covered in dense forests, this region harbors a rich diversity of flora and fauna, including numerous endemic species. Although sparsely populated, the region's communities have livelihoods and cultural practices deeply intertwined with the natural landscape. Its ecological wealth has been preserved over the years due to its environmental significance and cultural heritage. Additionally, the Upper Siang basin holds immense strategic importance due to its proximity to international borders, offering potential leverage in regional security and resource management. The SUMP aims to harness the river's energy for economic growth, proposing infrastructure that includes an 11,000 MW "mega dam," power stations, and transmission lines that could transform the state into a renewable energy hub. Proponents argue that the project will boost the state's economy through power generation, employment, and enhanced infrastructure while also helping meet the country's clean energy targets. However, a local NGO has raised concerns about the ecological and social costs of SUMP. The project would require extensive forest clearance, which plays a crucial role in carbon sequestration. Additionally, experts warn that construction activities could disturb the region's delicate ecosystems. This may affect riverine biodiversity and increase the risk of soil erosion and sedimentation, with potential downstream effects on agriculture and water quality. Another major issue raised is the potential displacement and cultural impact on local communities. This could threaten their subsistence-based livelihoods and disrupt their way of life. Critics also highlight that the project may contradict India's commitments to sustainable development. Despite these concerns, supporters of the project argue that SUMP's strategic importance and clean energy potential cannot be ignored. Moreover, they emphasize the project's strategic location, which would strengthen energy security, reduce regional inequalities, and contribute to the country's long-term development goals. They argue that amidst rising energy demands, the country cannot afford to forgo such an opportunity, especially given the presence of hydroelectric projects across borders that could shift regional control over water resources. (a) What are the ethical issues involved in the above case? (b) In your opinion, which should take priority between development and conservation, and why?
Chitwan Jain, AIR 17, 2025
This case gives classic dilemma of choosing between two rights wherein there is moral implicit.
Options (Pro project, Pro Tribals)
| One right | Another right | |---|---| | Clean Energy security for India | Right of tribals over land | | Harnessing strategic location over international border | Cultural legacy of forest | | Economic growth | Displacement of communities | | Employment generation | Cost of project in ecological terms |
a) Ethical issues involved
(POV of pro Development)
1. May hamper right to employment 2. Violation of fundamental right to equality 3. Issue of regional inequality that will be solved if project builds 4. Clash between security (Energy security) and (tribal security)
(POV of tribals) - if project is allowed
1. Hampers right to livelihood with Article 21 2. Threat of displacement 3. Erosion of cultural value of river and forest
(POV of environment)
1. National interest of border v/s ecological interest of biodiversity 2. Violates sustainable development goals. 3. Undermines value of existing resources for new resources
b) In my opinion, one must prioritize in following way ->
1. Viability assessment for taking objective decision 2. Talk to tribals as well as pro development group to create reconciliation 3. Emotionally and logically both demands must be weighed
Thus I will not choose extreme of development or Preservation but work on Middle path as prescribed by Buddha due to following reasons ->