Arushi is a young IPS officer known for her competence, integrity, and relentless dedication to challenging tasks. Recognizing her excellent track record, her superiors have chosen her to handle a sensitive assignment in a tribal-dominated district notorious for illegal bauxite mining. Here, the mafia mines bauxite from mineral-rich lands, transports it by truck, and sells it on the black market. This illegal operation thrives with the support of certain local officials and tribal musclemen who intimidate the local population and bribe select poor tribals to maintain control and silence. Upon assuming the new role, Arushi quickly grasps the ground realities and identifies the mafia's modus operandi, characterized by a series of devious tactics. Her inquiries reveal that several employees in her office are colluding with the mafia, forming an unholy nexus that enables these illegal operations. Determined to dismantle this network, she initiates strict actions, including raids on trucks transporting illegally mined bauxite. These actions significantly disrupt the mafia's operations, unsettling criminals unaccustomed to such resistance. Some office employees allegedly allied with the mafia inform the criminals of her determination to dismantle their operations, posing a serious threat to their profits. In response, the mafia adopts a counter-offensive strategy. Tribal strongmen and mafia operatives begin issuing direct threats to her, warning of severe consequences if the raids continue. Her family (husband and elderly mother) are stalked and placed under virtual surveillance, causing mental anguish and stress for them all. Matters assume serious propositions when a muscleman appears in her office and threatens that if she does not halt raids, etc., she will suffer the same fate as a predecessor officer who was killed by the mafia a decade earlier. a) Discuss the ethical issues involved in this case. b) Identify and evaluate the different options available to Arushi under the given situation. c) Which option would she adopt and why?
Chitwan Jain, AIR 17, 2025
This case can be felt similar to civil servant Durga Shakti Nagpal who lost life to illegal mining mafia, showcasing unholy nexus between (Public servants and Criminal mafia)
Priorities in case
1. To continue dismantling illegal mining without fear 2. Identify and punish who are colluding with criminal 3. Rescue family to safe hideout.
a) Ethical Issues involved
1. Breach of Rule of law by illegal mining of Bauxite, i.e. critical mineral 2. Dilution of public duty by officers who joined criminals 3. Moral myopia of profit over environment for minor. 4. Clash between safety of family and adherence to duty. 5. Threat of life to IPS Arushi herself 6. Misuse of power by mafia and tribalmen who killed officer earlier
b) Options and evaluation
1. Let the matter go and act under self preservation.
| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Security to family | Setting wrong precedent | | Safety to own life | Crisis of conscience | | Gain due to collusive corruption | Dilution of public duty |
2. Continue to raid and don't fear about death
| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Can lead to end of illegal mining. | Harm to family and self. | | Serving public duty of civil service oath | No long term change if Arushi is killed |
3. Inform seniors about issue, gather stronger team, safe hideout for family and continue to raid mafia
| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Organized approach | Mafia might still find and harm family | | Strict action against criminals | Seniors may not respond |
c) Choice of option and justification
I will choose option (3) which will ensure following ->
1. Not giving up against threat 2. Safety for family 3. New team to get end of corrupt officers 4. Inform seniors to ensure punishment for culprit and backup
why)
1. This will ensure I uphold principle of Nation above self which is Fiduciary duty of civil servant. 2. Set right precedent as being civil servant successors will look upto me. 3. Ensure strict action against mafia with stronger team to multiply my effort and ensure Justice is served. 4. Upholds Rule of Law as Bauxite is critically important for growth of technological India. 5. Ensures safety for family thereby managing personal and public duty
Thus one must be like Malala who got shot but still continued to fight for Right