Topper Copies

'Emergency' is one of the most controversial and widely debated events in Indian politics. How far do you agree with the view that it was imposed to fulfil individual political goals rather than serve national interests? Also, discuss the short-term and long-term impacts of the Emergency.

Chitwan Jain, AIR 17, 2025

Emergency is imposed under Article - 352, 356 and 360 of Indian constitution on various grounds like war, External aggression, internal armed rebellion, failure of state machinery and financial grounds.

Controversies and debates around Emergency - Misused to fulfil selfish political agenda - Tries to curb fundamental right to speech and expression - Vague internal disturbance ground (replaced via 44th amendment) - Tool to suppress opposition in politics

Imposed to fulfil political goals 1. Emergency of 1975 saw widespread protests and mass arrest of opposition 2. Emergency government tried to amend constitution arbitrarily 3. Tussle between Judiciary and legislature (eg) [Raj Narain case] 4. No role of ministers only top leadership was involved.

Other measures -> not political 1. Violent protest was being planned as alleged by INC 2. Opposition urged army to boycott -> creating security tensions. 3. Emergencies like 1960s and Kargil war imposed to protect sovereignty 4. Restricted freedom of speech to curb hate speech and communal clashes.

Short term Impacts 1. Article 350-360 mentions about Suspension of article 32 -> remedy of SC 2. President's proclamation -> suspend any fundamental right (except 20 and 21) 3. Change in financial and centre-state admin. relations (eg) centre can advice state on policy 4. Extension to centre and state legislature 5. President can give functions and take functions to state. 6. Centre can make laws on state list

Long term impacts 1. Misuse can erode trust of public 2. Chances of centre-state tussles (finances, Administration) 3. Arbitrary use -> demands for autonomy and separatist tendency. 4. Denial of justice -> feeling of hatred

Thus Emergency is extra-ordinary tool and must be used with extra-ordinary care.