Assess the effectiveness of welfare schemes for vulnerable sections in India and suggest measures to enhance their performance.
Sanskriti Trivedy, AIR 17, 2024
India being a welfare state aims to reduce inequalities under DPSP 38 and conserve vulnerable sector under DPSP 46.
The various schemes have done well
1. Empowerment - women reservation under PRIs have brought women issues to discussion 2. Participation - SC/ST reservation in Centre & states have ensured truly representative democracy 3. Conservation of unique elements of sectors like tribes under 5th & 8th Schedule; PESA Act 1996, FRA 2006 etc 4. Social mobility is visible in SC/ST/OBC through reservation policies 5. Improving outcomes in income - (eg) through SHGs for women - Lakhpati Didi 6. Psychological strength and dignity - (eg) to manual scavengers through technological intervention v/z Bandikut robot, Namaste scheme.
But they have fallen short - as
1. Lack of budgetary outlay - (eg) Gender Budgeting shown reduced expenditure 2. Lack of skill development and capacity building - focus on short term welfare (eg) additional ration during COVID 3. Issues of discrimination remains (eg) discrimination in mid day meal (Institute of Dalit Studies) 4. Legal measures have fallen short (eg) FRA 2006 did not recognise community rights in certain regions 5. Lack of equitable distribution of benefits thus demands for sub categorisation (eg) caste census demands in Bihar
Measures to enhance performance
1. Assess and allocate suitable outlays - like MGNREGA needs enhancement 2. Ensure institutions at place to actualise the schemes (eg) school infrastructure to support RTE 3. have grievance redressal and social audit to check the schemes (eg) MKSS in MGNREGA -> RTI movement 4. laws to be followed in spirit (eg) end Sarpanch Pati syndrome 5. check inclusion & exclusion errors (eg) for PDS beneficiary - ONOR scheme
Vulnerable thus need holistic support from the state to ensure social justice - Sabka Sath Sabka vikas