Topper Copies

The role of Election Commission of India has evolved beyond conducting elections to becoming a guardian of electoral democracy. Critically evaluate.

Sanskriti Trivedy, AIR 17, 2024

ECI is a constitutional body under article 324 made to conduct elections in a free and fair manner which is a basic structure under Indira Gandhi v/s Raj Narain case.

Role of ECI to conduct elections

1. Enrolment of voters and publish electoral rolls to clear out any discrepancy and ensure universal adult franchise (article 325) 2. Clear communication regarding dates etc of elections so that any candidate can apply (eg) SVEEP for voter awareness 3. Model code of conduct to ensure principled election campaign since 1966. 4. checking criminalization of politics -> affidavit (PUCL case, ADR case 2002) -> reprimand for instigating speeches (eg) cancel star campaigner status 5. have observers like election expenditure to ensure transparency in process 6. use tech like VVPAT, EVMs

Associated Challenges

1. Legal loopholes remain (eg) under RPA 1951, those not convicted yet can contest elections thus criminalization -> also ECI cant cancel party registration 2. Model code of Conduct - lacks legal backing only moral force 3. EVM, VVPATs - become embroiled in controversy regarding hacking 4. Identity politics and communal speeches still given also use of social media to polarise elections - where ECI has limited role.

Remedial Measures

1. Model code of conduct to get legal backing 2. ECI to be made more independent to ensure greater trust (eg) Anoop Baranwal case suggested have CJI as part to choose CEC - this to be deliberated 3. Legal remedies in RPA1951 - to ensure those having serious complaints cant contest 4. ECI should have power to cancel party registration 5. Greater support from district administration and police to ensure peaceful voting. 6. Voter awareness to ensure identity politics doesnt win votes.

ECI has emerged as key guardians of Indian democracy. SY Qureshi (ex CEC) calls it "Undocumented Wonder" for successfully conducting 18 central and 400+ state elections