Topper Copies

धर्मनिरपेक्षता के प्रति भारत का दृष्टिकोण न केवल अंतर-धार्मिक प्रभुत्व को चुनौती देता है, बल्कि अंतरा-धार्मिक प्रभुत्व को भी चुनौती देता है। विवेचना कीजिए। / India's approach to secularism does not merely challenge inter-religious domination but intra-religious domination as well. Discuss.

Sanskriti Trivedy, AIR 17, 2024

Secularism is one of most prominent ideologies of modern times and seeks separation of state from religion. It is result of European enlightenment post European Dark Age.

Secularism - challenge to Inter religious domination

1. Aims to establish equality of religions and no state religion to impact the policies 2. Gives space for each religion to grow as people are allowed to propagate and profess as per article 25 3. Against communalism and violence which are legacies of British rule. Give space for practice 4. Protection of minorities, to ensure that 19% religious minorities also develop (census 2011) - eg) articles 29-30; Naimenzil etc

Secularism - challenges intra domination as well

1. Aims to end any practise that is discriminatory and not essential practise - eg) Shirur Mutt case said only essential practises; Sabrimala verdict to allow women 2. Aims to establish equitable society - eg) against varna based untouchability focus on equity article 17 3. Aims to support reform within religion - eg) discussions on UCC, Triple Talaq abolished 4. Against dogmatic and inhumane practice like witch-hunting, human sacrifices seen in some indigenous tribal religions

But some concerns remain - communalism seen (eg) Udaipur mob lynching - Sachar committee - minorities are underdeveloped - Debates on UCC

In this situation, Indian secularism needs to re-invent itself to start with commitment of welfare state (article 38) and Sarva Dharma Sambhav