Topper Copies

Throw light on the various mechanisms for the settlement of disputes related to the equitable sharing of river water among states. Also, evaluate the effectiveness of these mechanisms in the resolution of inter-state river water disputes in the country.

Sanskriti Trivedy, AIR 17, 2024

Given the huge size and varying topography of India, inter state water disputes are result of geography but take political shape (eg) Mahanadi Dispute; Cauvery Dispute

Reasons for Dispute

1. Boundaries of states are historical, political - geography adds to conflict 2. Water scarcity as not all rivers are perennial and climate change induces stress 3. Institutional and legal measures have limits to success 4. Regionalism is manifested by this

Various Mechanisms available

1. Under constitution article 262 provides for interstate water dispute resolution by centre and keeps courts out of this. 2. Water is a state subject but inter state dispute/management of water is union list (article 246, 7th schedule) 3. River Boards Act - provide for river water usage. 4. Inter State Water Disputes Act - Aim to make tribunals to solve any dispute 5. Though courts are barred, certain dispute under article 131. 6. Inter state Council/zonal council - are also institutions of discussion 7. Article 136 - Special leave petition of Supreme Court is also used (eg) in Cauvery water dispute

But limited success because

1. Though courts are barring entry, many decisions of tribunals have gone to courts (eg) Mahadayi dispute 2. Tribunals under ISWD 1956 were delayed (eg) It took 20 years to form Cauvery dispute tribunal 3. Water disputes spill over to political and identity issues (eg) Sutlej-Yamuna issue between Punjab-Haryana mixed with Khalistani sentiments 4. River Boards Act - River boards not yet formed 5. Inter State Council - only advisory with no clear ruling given 6. Many issues not discussed in tribunal - eg of dam Hullapenjar

Solution

In this situation - Revamp tribunals like a single tribunal made in 2019 - some suggest to give courts the power - deliberation among states

Democratic processes with involvement of experts and civil society can solve these issues.