Assess the success of the 73rd Constitutional Amendment Act in strengthening Panchayati Raj Institutions in India.
Sanskriti Trivedy, AIR 17, 2024
73rd constitution amendment result of multiple committee recommendation (Singhvi) and civil society efforts lays down constitutionalisation of Panchayati Raj System (PRIs) in line with DPSP 40.
Success of 73rd Amendment
1. Participatory - Gram Sabha is the nodal body to make decisions and allows participation by all above 18 years old whose name is in electoral rolls - Through participation local plans are made at PRIs at three tiers - village, intermediate, district - Social Audits are important part to bring the bodies accountable to people. - In many regions decision on local water body use, development plans - have to be approved by Gram Sabhas 2. Inclusive - Reservation provided at all three tiers - women 1/3rd and SC/ST according to population - Even OBC reservation is optional provision - Ensuring participation by tribes in 5th schedule region under PESA Act 1996 - Skill Development to increase inclusive nature (Gram Swarajya Abhiyan)
But concerns on success
1. Gram Sabhas not formed in many states; the elections to PRIs are delayed (Bihar) 2. The local plans are just on paper because there is lack of legislative, financial and administrative decentralisation by state. (2nd ARC, 6th Report) 3. Social Audits are not regularly held. 4. Parastatals take the place of elected bodies (eg) Rural Health Board. 5. Reserved seats are under rotation thus lack of actual empowerment. 6. "Sarpanch Pati" - patriarchal usurpation by men of womens seats 7. Lack of local taxation - thus reduced scope for local accountability (M/oRD report)
In this situation, PRIs need to be empowered with own finances, given powers as per 11th schedule and regular elections need to be conducted.