Topper Copies

Discuss the reasons behind the declining productivity of Parliament as a deliberative body, and suggest remedial measures.

Sanskriti Trivedy, AIR 17, 2024

Parliament is the key representative body at the central level consisting of the Lok Sabha, Rajya Sabha and President.

Reasons for parliamentary decline

1. Rise of dominant party system - where BJP has absolute majority, this reduces the scope for inter party discussion. 2. Rise of polarisation on issues leads to disruptions (eg) debates on article 370 repeal 3. Parties now are ideologically similar "catchall" thus finding issues of identity politics - like caste, religion to debate upon. 4. Parliamentarians credentials under questions as 43% faced criminal case (ADR) -> poor quality of debate. 5. opposition criticises the speaker of partisan inclination. 6. Regional parties finding space at national level thus multiple demands raised thus increase in conflict. 7. Reduces time between introduction of bill and its passing - public cant give opinion - fall in deliberation.

In this situation, remedial measures

1. Committees to be reinvented by giving more tooth as seen in USA. 2. Parliamentary conduct rules to be strictly adhered. Ensure punishment to miscreants through Ethics & Privilege committees 3. Address Criminalization of politics - amend RPA for disallowing chargesheeted MPs 4. Speaker to be made neutral like in UK - where he leaves party. 5. Greater space for public debates through civil society like PRS, ADR etc.

Yet, Parliament is still important as - democratic processes followed - microcosm of India - vulnerable section represented (SC/ST)

("decline" is a strong term)

Thus with suitable steps parliament has to ensure peoples trust on the institution to ensure legitimacy of the laws made.