To what extent have farmer associations been successful in influencing public policies and governance in the country?
Sanskriti Trivedy, AIR 17, 2024
Pressure groups are non party political processes that engage with government to influence it through advocacy, lobbying and electioneering
Some farmer pressure group - All India Kisan Sabha (1936) - All India Kisan Union - BKSS
Farmer groups successful
1. To secure direct and indirect subsidies (eg) electricity, seeds etc 2. To ask for greater farmers participation (eg) against farm laws (2020) because against lack of deliberation. 3. Policy advocacy through research (eg) MSP legalisation is being discussed 4. Pressure groups also support parties that are pro-farmers (eg) Punjab elections 5. To secure policies at international fora like WTO.
But the concerns remain
1. Party affiliation thus lack of independent voice 2. Dominated by large farmers called Bullock capitalist - dont discuss issue of small & marginal farmers 3. At many times under direct confrontation, lack of collaboration during farm law protests 4. Certain demands have not met (eg) MSP legalisation, C-2 method of MSP calculation 5. Lack of coordination with other groups like environmental groups to form consolidated policy
India is primarily agrarian and thus voice of farmers have to be heard and addressed to ensure inclusive growth.