ब्राह्मणवाद और बौद्ध धर्म के बीच अर्थ, अनुयायियों और विचारधारा को लेकर हुई प्रतिस्पर्धात्मक एवं शत्रुतापूर्ण गतिशीलता ने किस प्रकार बौद्ध धर्म के पतन में भूमिका निभाई? / How did the competitive and hostile dynamic between Brahminism and Buddhism over funding, followers, and ideology mark the decline of Buddhism?
Sanskriti Trivedy, AIR 17, 2024
Buddhism was the non orthodox religion that started in 6th c BC pioneered by Siddhartha in present day Bihar-Nepal, while Brahminism is a hegemonic foundation of ancient Hindu thought based on varna classification.
Competitive Dynamic leading to fall of Buddhism can be seen by
Funding
(a) The patronage to Buddhism fell gradually and post Pala period, it drastically fell (b) Major patronage to Buddhism was given by Ashoka, Indo Greeks and Kushanas; later kingdoms were apprehensive about Buddhism - eg) Mahendravarman I wrote Mattavilasa Prahasanam to mock Buddhism (c) Patronage to Brahminism rose post Palas by Rashtrakutas, Southern kingdoms
Followers
(a) Ancient kingdoms supported Buddhism like Ashoka and later Mauryas (b) Indo Greeks supported Buddhism - eg) Gandhara and Mathura schools of art grew (c) In southern India, Jainism was prominent apart from Brahminism, thus Buddhist followers declined (d) Brahminism by the Brahmans while Buddhism by Vaishyas (working class)
Ideology
There were differences between the two:
| Buddhism | Brahminism | |---|---| | Non orthodox, against Brahminic value system | Orthodox, driven by Brahman's Supremacy in Chaturvarna system | | More egalitarian | Very hierarchical; segmented | | Wider participation in religion and social activities by all | Participation restricted by varna (eg) women, shudras not allowed to read vedas | | Easier procedures | Tough to practise, expensive and elaborate rituals (eg) the festivals; the sacrifices (Hiranyagarbha) |
But both can't be separated as there were exchanges too - visit of Buddha to non Buddhist kingdom like Anga, and the architecture has both elements - eg) Ajanta caves
Buddhism - Brahmanism learnt from each other
Today both are our ideological legacy and give deep insight into cultural lives of the past - eg) Recent Nalanda university renovated - taught elements of both