The Presidents of India and USA differ not just the manner in which they are elected but also with respect to their powers. Elucidate.
Sanskriti Trivedy, AIR 17, 2024
President in India is nominal head, for USA has presidential system, real head.
Election Processes
India 1. Indirect Election 2. People Not involved 3. State involved (Rajya Sabha) and representatives at Centre 4. Debates dont happen
USA 1. Direct Election and Indirect election 2. People involved in selecting party candidate 3. people vote for -> electoral group/college -> this votes for president 4. Debates are important part 5. Senate not involved in election
Powers
India 1. Nominal head 2. De Jure head 3. Advice of council of minister binding 4. Can dissolve legislature 5. all legislation & executive actions in his frame 6. head of armed forces 7. can promulgate ordinance 8. veto is limited
USA 1. Real a head 2. Lack of accountability due to clear power separation 3. chooses its own secretaries - can remove them anytime 4. cant dissolve congress 5. absolute veto 6. Role in judicial appointment indirect & strong 7. ordinance not promulgated 8. called the 1st office
India adopted the parliamentary system because of its commitment to responsibility of executive even though American presidential system promise stability.