Though Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRIs) have become a platform for competitive politics, they have not emerged as an agency of planning and service delivery. Why? (Answer in 250 words)
Sanskriti Trivedy, AIR 17, 2024
PRIs are constitutionally decentralised bodies of local self government under 73rd constitutional amendment Act 1993 through part 9.
PRIs as - competitive politics 1. Due to constitutionally mandated elections every 5 years, local parties have blossomed 2. Even national & state level parties participate and support candidates (eg) in Punjab - AAP also 3. The trends of Panchayat levels is reflected in national & state level concerns 4. As reservation for SC, STs and women present - gives scope for identity politics
Thus PRI elections are microcosm of the democratic milieu of India.
But not emerged as planning & service delivery institute as 1. Lack of funds as lack of own taxation (2nd ARC); transfers from State & central finance commission are not met (M/o PRI report) 2. The states are apprehensive about devolution of functions as per schedule 11 (Activity Mapping) (Mani Shankar Aiyar committee) - also there is duplication as States and PRIs have same subject 3. Administrative decentralisation is also weak as bureaucrats hold on to offices - M/o PRI notes even the people don't want to take responsibility 4. The parastatals bypass the elected PRIs as we see bodies like Rural Development Associations get funds but PRIs lack funds 5. As reserved seats rotate, there is continued politics and contestation but lack of activism 6. PRIs lack even basic infrastructure, cadastral maps and data to formulate policies 7. Reservation & Social Justice as token as Sarpanch Pati system
Thus solutions: - 2nd ARC - getting rid of parastatals - Mani Shankar Aiyar Committee - Activity Mapping
Thus there is need to learn from states like Kerala and abide by principle of Subsidiarity (2nd ARC) and empower PRIs.