How far do you agree with the view that the National Green Tribunal (NGT) has met its objective of ensuring environmental justice in India? (Answer in 250 words)
Sanskriti Trivedy, AIR 17, 2024
NGT is a statutory body under NGT Act 2010 that gives an alternative route to environmental laws to ensure true right to clean environment as per article 21.
NGT - successful in environmental justice 1. Its alternative justice approach has made courts accessible 2. Taken suo moto cases against issues (eg) Delhi's coal fired plants pollution 3. As it is a tribunal - also has experts to have meaningful judgements 4. As it is driven by Principles of Natural Justice and not strict provisions as per CrPC, IPC, more approachable 5. Faster resolution of disputes also gives relief to courts that have huge pendency (4.9cr cases CPCB) 6. Appeals have been allowed thus respite exists
But NGT - has shortcomings 1. Appeals only in Supreme Court within 90 days - thus burden on Supreme court and also lesser time to file appeals 2. Certain laws are exempted lki WPA 1972, BDA 2002 - thus limited number of cases 3. Criticised as being limited to urban elite cases and misses touch from grassroots (eg) tribal rights due to mining 4. NGT can give only rulings and can't ensure that its rulings are implemented, have to depend on law machinery
In this situation, solution 1. NGT to research and collaborate more with experts and indigenous communities 2. The appeals period should be expanded 3. Grassroot movements have to form a voice
As per Ranjit Singh case (2024), clean environment is a basic fundamental right. As our environmental movements gets consciousness - need for NGT to act as a bulwark of justice.