Topper Copies

Both India and the USA adhere to democratic principles but their electoral systems exhibit significant differences. What are the key differences in electoral practices between the two countries? (Answer in 250 words)

Sanskriti Trivedy, AIR 17, 2024

India is the largest democracy since 1947 while USA is the oldest since 1776.

Both adhere to democratic principles as 1. Liberty, Equality, Fraternity part of fundamental rights (India) and bill of rights (US) 2. Participation of people ensured through regular elections at state, central level 3. Representative Institutions exist -> Parliament (India), Congress, Senate (USA) 4. Civil society, media freedom ensures transparency and accountability in both 5. Judiciary seeks the proper functioning of the democratic systems

Key differences in electoral practices

| USA | India | |---|---| | 1. 2 tiered governance and electoral systems | 1. India has 3 tiered systems as Panchayats, Municipalities | | 2. The election of president is by an elaborate process (Direct): primaries -> electoral college -> presidential election | 2. The election of president is Indirect, by State and central level legislatures | | 3. No separate body for elections | 3. Separate Election Commission of India exists | | 4. Allows for postal, online votes | 4. Postal votes are allowed only in few situations (eg) armed forces | | 5. Governor at each state is directly elected | 5. Governor at each state appointed by centre | | 6. 'Winner takes all' follows | 6. There, winner takes all doesn't follow | | 7. Electoral petition not in judiciary | 7. HC entertains electoral petition |

However similarities: election campaign & elaborate; foundational pillars of democracies.

Thus both countries have enough to learn from each other and act as role models for democratic deepening.