Topper Copies

Governors in India often overstep their constitutional role and fail to act effectively when needed. Comment. (Answer in 250 words)

Sanskriti Trivedy, AIR 17, 2024

Governors are executive appointments by president at the State as nominal heads under article 153.

Governors - overstepping their role 1. To reserve bills for presidential suggestion even after being passed by state for the second time (in case of Punjab) 2. To seek article 356 and dissolve government at states with different parties (eg) seen in Jharkhand 3. To change the speech of governor's address eventhough it has to be representative of government's wishes (eg) - TN governor 4. To not allow majority party to form government and allowing alternative (eg) Karnataka - BJP led government formed overnight

Failing to act effectively when needed 1. Their role as chancellors debated as excess of powers seen 2. Not checking the majority on the floor of the house as per Bommai case guidelines and dissolving governments (eg) - Maharashtra 3. To reserve bills of importance to act as obstruction 4. As constitution gives discretionary power; it is misused

This happens because 1. Governor act as long arm of centre (Puchhi commission) 2. Appointment of governor completely under centre :. partisan behaviours

Thus solution lies in 1. Adhering to Raghukul Tilak case - governor not just central appointment 2. Puchhi, Sarkaria commission - suggested to have CM of the state's approval 3. To not reserve bills second time passed by state (SC in Punjab case)

Governors are 'sages' first are crucial to ensure communication between the federal units, thus have to be treated as office of dignity.