While the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) plays a crucial role in combating corruption, its functioning is often criticized for being partisan and acting against the federal spirit. Discuss with the help of suitable examples. (Answer in 250 words)
Sanskriti Trivedy, AIR 17, 2024
CBI is a investigative body formed under DPSE Act 1946 and is further operationalised through CVC Act 2003 and Lokpal Act 2013.
CBI - in combating corruption 1. Has important role in Prevention of Corruption Act investigations 2. Work closely with other bodies lki CVC, Lokpal and ED to seek accountability 3. Has held public servants and public policies under radar
Some success stories: - 2G scam - Adarsh society
But criticism due to partisan is seen as 1. Justice Lodha said that due to central appointment, CBI is caged parrot and only speaks master's voice 2. Lack of transparency and autonomy in functions as often gets bypassed under section 8 of RTI because deals with sensitive cases 3. Used for settling political vendetta by ruling parties as often very low conviction 4. Tampering with evidence
Criticism - against federal spirit 1. As central body, takes precedence over state police (police = state list) 2. Despite having general consent provision; the consent is bypassed 3. Used mostly in cases of states not ruled by the ruling party at the centre
However certain positive roles 1. Interpol appreciates its functioning 2. Speedy investigations conducted 3. Recently using high level tech for thorough investigations
In this situation, reforms 1. As per Vineet Narain case gave it legal structure as per CVC 2. LK Mishra committee also suggests transparency
As India is moving towards 'clean government' (budget 2018), need to reform and trust build in institutions lki CBI.