Topper Copies

Q.12) In the lush green expanse of the Eastern Ghats, a significant change is underway. The state government has announced a new infrastructure project-a highway connecting City A and City B. This project, envisioned as a catalyst for economic growth and enhanced connectivity, also promises to attract significant investments, including from a major semiconductor company. The semiconductor company is important for strategic purposes, given the growing importance of semiconductors in defense, space, and communications sectors. However, the proposed highway passes through a densely forested tribal area, home to an indigenous community deeply connected to the land. The local tribal community, reliant on the forest for their livelihood and cultural practices, is alarmed by the prospect of displacement and the extensive forest clearance required by the project. The forest is not just their home but a crucial part of their identity and source of livelihood. It is where their ancestors are buried, where they grow medicinal plants, and where their children play. The community's leaders, including Meera, a respected elder, are determined to protect their land. They fear losing their ancestral lands and the destruction of their way of life. Determined to make their voices heard, the community organizes a protest march to the office of the District Magistrate and seeks time to meet the DM. The DM, Vikash known for his fair and balanced approach, listens intently as Meera and other leaders explain their fears. They asserted their legally protected right to manage and protect the forest. Meanwhile, in the corporate offices of M&T Infrastructure Ltd., CEO Sunil is grappling with the growing unrest. The company has been contracted to build the highway, but the resistance from the tribal community poses a significant challenge. Delays could lead to escalating costs and potential project failure. Sunil decides to seek a meeting with Saritha, the Chief Secretary of State, to discuss the situation. Saritha, overseeing the project from the state secretariat, is aware of the delicate balance needed. The project is crucial for the state's development and aligns with the policy of promoting ease of doing business. Moreover, the potential investment from the semiconductor company is strategically important for both the state and the nation. Any delay or hindrance could tarnish the state's reputation and dissuade future investments. When Sunil meets Saritha, he lays out his concerns. "Madam Secretary, the protests are intensifying. If this continues, we might have to consider withdrawing from the project. The financial risks are becoming untenable." The ruling party, keen to maintain its pro-development image, wants early completion of the project and the materialization of the semiconductor manufacturing plant to fulfill its poll promises. The Chief Secretary conveys the policy of the state government and the concerns of M&T Infrastructure Ltd. to the District Magistrate of the district concerned. As the administrative head of the district, the responsibility for maintaining law and order and facilitating development projects rests upon him. a. What are the ethical issues involved in the case? b. Evaluate the options available to Vikash, being District Magistrate of the area. c. What course of action should Vikash adopt and why?

Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025

The above case study highlights the dichotomy between development and environmental conservation. It also shows how a civil servant navigates through complex web of challenges when competing interests are at play.

a) Ethical Issues

1. Strategic Importance of Semiconductor industry and lack of adequate infrastructure <-> Self Reliance 2. Inclusive economic growth and grievances from various stakeholders (Tribes, Business men etc) 3. Environmental conservation amidst felling of trees which act as carbon sink - meeting Panchamrit Goals 4. Ease of Doing Business and Profit motives of Business men 5. lives and livelihoods of Tribals adversely impacted due to displacement

b) Options available to Vikash

Option I - Give clearance to Project for development - Pros: (i) Strategic development (ii) Ease of doing Business - Cons: (i) Against Tribal rights (ii) Violation of Environmental ethics

Option II - Hold the project and deny approval - Pros: (i) Ecocentrism (ii) Rights Based approach (iii) Short term Gains vs long term Sustainability (iv) Preservation of forests - Cons: (i) Hinders ease of doing Business (ii) Political Interference (iii) Against Strategic Interests

Option III - Resign from Position - Pros: (i) No ethical dilemma - Cons: (i) Escapist attitude

Option IV - Set up expert Committee under EIA, SIA and Project evaluation - Pros: (i) Objective decision making (ii) Integrated approach (iii) Procedural Integrity - Cons: (i) Delay in Project Completion (ii) Political Backlash

c) Course of action to be adopted

1. Setup Environmental expert committee in alignment with Environmental Impact Assessment and Social Impact Assessment 2. Findings of Social costs of Project and do Cost Benefit analysis 3. Ensure updated Baseline data 4. Adequate representation of diverse Stakeholders in committee - Tribes, Businessmen, Political Representative, Environment expert 5. Meanwhile look for alternative sites for project and land available based on land records 6. As per EIA and SIA reports, take final decision 7. If Benefits outweighs costs, plan an empathetic and compensatory Rehabilitation Policy for displaced communities 8. If costs outweighs Benefits, communicate same to CEO and do proper documentation regarding denial of approval. Offer alternative land and fast track clearances to reduce cost overrun

Ease of Doing Business is significant for Viksit Bharat @ 2047, however it must be balanced with Saptrishi Goals of Budget (inclusive development, reaching last mile, bridging gaps).