Topper Copies

Q.10) Littering at popular tourist destinations has become a significant environmental and ethical concern in India. A recent incident highlighted this issue when tourists were observed throwing tissue papers and a cake box on the road after celebrating a birthday. When a local politely requested them to use a nearby dustbin just 5 feet away, the tourists dismissed the appeal, claiming no dustbin was available. The situation escalated when their driver threw a plastic bag into the adjacent valley. Public reactions to the incident were divided. Some individuals commended the intervention as an effort to promote civic responsibility, emphasizing the need to protect fragile ecosystems like hill stations. Many argued that tourists must adhere to basic environmental ethics and that public spaces are a shared responsibility. Critics also highlighted the broader implications of such irresponsible behavior on the environment and local livelihoods. On the other hand, the tourists involved accused those intervening of interfering in their personal affairs, claiming their privacy was being violated. The argument that the tourists were being publicly shamed through the viral video added another layer to the ethical debate. Many questioned whether posting such incidents online, even for a social cause, was appropriate or necessary. The debate continues, with one side emphasizing the collective responsibility to preserve public spaces and the environment, while the other raises concerns about individual privacy and autonomy. a. What are the ethical concerns associated with tourists littering at public destinations? b. How can ethical tourism practices be integrated into policies to address issues like littering at tourist destinations? c. Suggest a course of action that balances environmental responsibility and individual rights. Justify your answer.

Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025

The above case study highlights ethical dilemmas in public life which can also impact ethical issues of personal life. Managing divergences and overlap between ethics in public and private life might need attitude change and emotional Intelligence.

a) Ethical Concerns Associated

1. Negative attitude towards environment conservation <-> Not in My Backyard 2. lack of ecocentrism as putting self interests over nature interests 3. Unsustainability of such actions due to long term negative Impact 4. lack of Stewardship and accountability among people as seen with driver 5. using Environment and Mother Earth as means to achieve Recreational Purpose (ends) 6. Affects individuals, animals, plants and entire ecosystem -> minimises welfare (utilitarianism) - Microplastics found in marine species <-> Bio accumulation 7. Future impact on Tourism of such places - Adverse weather patterns in Uttarakhand due to unsustainable Tourism

b) Ethical Tourism should be based on below Principles

1. Adoption of environmental ethics as part of value education -> Role of Family, educational institutes -> Role of Society - NEP 2020 2. Infrastructure Support by putting dustbins nearby 3. Community Engagement to promote sustainable Tourism practises 4. Volunteers from local community for periodic cleanliness drives 5. Social Persuasion Strategies to change attitude - Swachh Bharat Mission -> Disgust -> Pride -> love 6. Adoption of Biodegradable materials and total plastic ban in tourist places more prone to pollution

c) Course of action to Balance Environmental Responsibility and Individual Rights

1. Integrated approach towards environment and not compartmentalisation - Mission Life -> Individual change -> Ecocentrism 2. Respecting human dignity (Kantian ethics) and protecting privacy at all costs - 'privacy' culture using Digital data protection Act and Right to privacy under Article 21 3. Choosing the right means to achieve sustainability - video recording and Public shaming against consent -> violates deontological ethics 4. Maximising welfare of everyone in the ecosystem - Nature Based Solutions to promote compostable waste/plastic 5. Research and development to promote environment friendly products - Nano materials 6. Community Engagement and capacity Building

Circular Economy as proposed under Panchamrit Goals and Self restraint to reduce Conspicuous consumption is need of the hour. Afterall, this is not our ecosystem and we have Borrowed it from our children.