Topper Copies

Differentiate between the clemency powers of the Presidents of India and the USA. Also, critically examine the vesting of clemency power in the executive.

Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025

India has a parliamentary system wherein President is the nominal head of state. US has Presidential system wherein he is the real head.

Many substantial differences exist b/w both

Clemency Powers

| US | India | |---|---| | a) US president has complete authority to decide on pardon/commute etc. | a) Indian Prez act on the advise of CoM not otherwise | | b) Powers: can pardon death sentence, even military orders etc. | b) A.72 -> power to commute, remit, respite, and pardon | | c) Prez is the final authority, can't be questioned | c) Can be under judicial scrutiny in exceptional cases | | d) Vested with real & wide pws to ensure judicial correction scope | d) Not real only nominal as PM act as real head and he advises |

Other differences

| US | India | |---|---| | Prez -less legislative power, full executive powers, chose VP | legislative, executive, judicial emergency powers |

Similarities a. Both can pardon death sentence b. Both can pardon sentences of military tribunals c. Can commute, remit also

Vesting clemency pws in Executive

Positives 1. Ensure checks on judicial powers & scope for correction 2. Gives executive discretion to ensure complete justice 3. Checks & balances between diff. organs of state 4. Ensure accountability of executive towards ensuring justice

Negative 1. Against seperation of powers 2. Potential for misuse of power 3. Politicisation chances as executive can use it for political gains 4. Hampers judicial independence & undermine its authority by reversing its judgement