Q.9) Inside a busy city administration office, Joint Municipal Commissioner Keerthi, who also serves as the Public Information Officer (PIO), faces a challenging situation. Recently, an RTI application has been received, demanding details about public infrastructure projects initiated during her tenure. Upon reviewing the requested information, Keerthi discovers that certain decisions made regarding these projects were not entirely sound in hindsight. These decisions, although taken in good faith and after due diligence, failed to realize promised outcomes. There were other employees also who were party to this decision. The disclosure of this information could potentially lead to scrutiny and backlash against herself, the employees, and contractors involved. Known for her integrity and commitment to public service, Keerthi finds herself at a crossroads. The RTI Act has served as a critical check against administrative arbitrariness, ensuring transparency and accountability. However, she also observes a troubling trend. RTI applications are often used by vested interests and activists seeking personal gain rather than genuine public interest. Some activists even resort to threats or extortion tactics, undermining the integrity of the RTI process. She fears the requested RTI information could be similarly exploited. Moreover, the employees involved are requesting her to withhold the information. In navigating this situation, Keerthi weighs her options carefully. a. Critically examine the options available to Keerthi in the above situation. b. Which of the above would be the most appropriate for Keerthi and why?
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
The above case study highlights how bonafide mistakes made by honest civil servants can lead to serious repercussions and might jeopardise their career. Multiple values at play might complicate the situation hence creating crisis of conscience.
a) Options available to Keerthi
Option I - Release the Information without second thoughts - Pros: (i) RTI purpose fulfilled (ii) Professional Integrity (iii) Freedom of Expression (Article 19(1)(a)) - Cons: (i) Career at risk (ii) Employees and Contractors also impacted (iii) Misuse of RTI for personal gains
Option II - Withhold the Information and deny RTI request seeking vague exemptions - Pros: (i) Career Intact (ii) Bonafide mistake can be Ignored (iii) Promotes Risk taking and Innovation in future - Cons: (i) Denial of Constitutional Rights (ii) Abuse of power via exemptions (iii) Truth will come out anyway
Option III - Resign from the job - Pros: (i) No conflict of Interest - Cons: (i) Future disciplinary action can be taken up
Option IV - Assess RTI request to find if frivolous and then take decision - Pros: (i) Objective decision making (ii) Puts unnecessary burden on government resources, if frivolous (iii) Fulfils the Spirit of RTI - Cons: (i) Re-application of RTI possible even if frivolous (ii) Denial of Information
Option V - Voluntary Public disclosure under Section 4 of RTI Act and release information under application too - Pros: (i) Integrity and Probity in governance (ii) Transparency and Accountability - Cons: (i) Possible disciplinary action
b) Keerthi's course of action
should be based on below - 1. Achieving 'spirit' of RTI act 2. Maintaining Professional Integrity despite adversity 3. Citizen empowerment using Public data 4. Team spirit
Course of Action
1. Voluntary disclosure under Section 4 of RTI Act along with possible side effects and outcomes which were unintended -> Taking ownership hence enhances accountability -> Effective communication by mentioning details of why and how of decision making 2. If RTI application is found to be frivolous, reject the application as it puts unnecessary strain on Resources 3. If RTI application is not frivolous, fulfill your duty as PIO (Duty based ethics) 4. Adopt Nishkam Karma and not thinking of outcomes 5. In case of future proceedings against you and team, do the groundwork to justify every decision taken using meeting Records, File Notings etc 6. Provide Professional counseling to the people involved and have faith in Criminal Justice system 7. Take measures to further improve project outcomes using feedback from citizen - eg. My gov
Long Term Measures
1. Process Reengineering to avoid Bonafide mistakes 2. Objective and Impartial decision making using Automation and emerging Technology 3. Seeking Third Party view on decisions 4. Capacity Building of Team
Governance is full of Complexities, navigating these challenges using highest standards of ethical governance would maximise good and minimise harm.