Topper Copies

Q.8) Ramesh is a ninth-class student of Shiksha Public School from a lower-middle-class family in a tier-3 city. He had a deep interest in creative arts like music and dance and had always excelled in them. Teachers and friends often praised his talent, and Ramesh dreamed of pursuing a career in performing arts. However, his parents envisioned a different path for him, which was becoming an engineer. Coming from modest backgrounds and facing financial difficulties, Ramesh's parents were banking on his engineering career to secure a stable and prosperous future. When Ramesh shared his dream with his parents, they strongly opposed it, as expected. His father dismissed his passion as unrealistic and said music and dance were not respectable professions. He also compared Ramesh to his cousin Mahesh, who had secured a high-paying job after graduating from a top engineering college. Ramesh felt pressured and reluctantly agreed to pursue science in school. After completing his board exams, his parents sent him to Kotanagar, a coaching hub known for engineering entrance exam preparation. To finance Ramesh's coaching fees, his parents mortgaged their only ancestral property, emphasizing the importance of Ramesh's success in the upcoming engineering entrance exams. Ramesh, torn between his dreams and his family's expectations, resolved to work hard. However, the demanding coaching schedule, coupled with his lack of interest in the subjects, began to take a toll on his mental health. Far from home, Ramesh felt isolated and depressed. He missed his friends, school environment, and the hobbies that once brought him joy. The pressure to perform was immense, with his mock test results consistently falling short of expectations. Over time, he began withdrawing from others, even avoiding phone calls with his parents. After two years of grueling preparation, Ramesh appeared for the entrance exam under the weight of crushing expectations. When the results were declared, he was unable to secure admission to a prestigious engineering college. The disappointment in his parents' voices further deepened his guilt and sense of failure. Feeling like a burden and unable to bear the weight of unmet expectations, Ramesh took a drastic step and ended his life by jumping from his hostel building. In his final note, Ramesh apologized to his parents for failing to meet their aspirations and expressed his regret for letting them down. a. Based on the above case study, discuss the ethical issues with the education system. b. What are the qualities lacked by Ramesh's parents? c. What qualities in a person can prevent them from taking the extreme step of suicide?

Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025

The above case study highlights the rising mental health issues and suicides among youth. Also, Social stigma and lack of family support aggravates such issues causing loss of precious lives.

a) Ethical Issues with Education System

1. Perception about multidisciplinary subjects like Music and dance -> 'less' worthy and usually taken up by 'Back benchers' (negative attitude) 2. Role of family in developing 'Bias' towards Science and picking a 'safe' option <-> lack of Innovation and risk averse attitude 3. lack of Conducive and healthy ecosystem provided by Kotanagar coachings -> Profit making motive -> Ignorance to mental health -> Breeds competition in unhealthy manner 4. lack of avenues and job opportunities among arts, music and dance due to skewed focus on STEM (Government Policy Paralysis) 5. Failure of society to provide right amount of counseling due to Social stigma towards depression 6. lack of Emotional Intelligence among youth <-> cannot handle pressure and failure

b) Qualities lacked by Ramesh's Parents

1. Unilateral decision making for the child without his consent <-> Forced decision making 2. Putting means vs ends: Adopting non-interesting subjects to get high paying jobs 3. lack of Respect towards Child hurts human dignity <-> Kantian ethics 4. Putting economical interests above empathy and compassion towards child 5. lack of Responsiveness and Ignorance towards deteriorating mental health despite early signs of depression 6. Inadequate approachability as Ramesh did not reach out to them <-> Poor inter personal Skills 7. lack of Emotional intelligence as too much focus on professional competence

c) Qualities that can prevent the extreme step

Nobody deserves to suffer in silence. Hence, focus should be drawn on development of below qualities in person:

1. Self-awareness of emotions about feeling depressed or feeling low 2. Developing Social Skills during school to enhance inter-personal relations - Panchakosha Principles of National Education Policy 2020 3. Effective communication and reaching out to seek professional help - Tele MANAS for counseling 4. Physical exercises like yoga to better mental health 5. Channelising negative emotions into positive - Dashrath Manjhi -> Mountain Man - Bhagat Singh -> Punjab Naujawan Sabha 6. Courage Building to speak up and build self-confidence - Martial classes during school 7. Attitude change towards mental health to fight isolation - Deepika Padukone Foundation 8. Acceptance of Failures as part and parcel of life by operant conditioning - sharing failure stories in NCERTs

Apart from person himself, Society should also take below measures -

1. Busting Social stigma, community initiatives - langar as community Service 2. Detect early signs of depression and report to professionals - IIT Guwahati Your DOST initiative 3. Value education in schools and role of family in building Resilience

When an individual takes his life, it does not merely show failure on his part but we fail as a society and as a nation. Mental health should be prioritised at the earliest to save various Ramesh(es).