Q.6) a) The risks to civilian aviation in conflict zones underscore the need for an ethical framework prioritizing human lives. Yet, the interplay of state interests and sovereignty complicates global responses. What ethical principles should guide nations in addressing aviation safety, and how can the international community address these risks?
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
The rising accidents of aviation industry has sparked discussion around addressing aviation safety. - eg. Air India crash killed more than 240 people
Risks to Civilian Aviation In conflict zones
1. Mis-calculated decision of treating civilian aircraft as military aircraft -> Wrong decision making 2. Closing of airspace during military conflicts -> Impacts Quality of life and Mobility - Pakistan closed its airspace led to diversion of Indian flights 3. lack of Regulatory framework
Ethical Principles Guiding Aviation safety in Military zones
1. Human Rights and dignity to be respected at all costs (Kantian ethics) 2. Greatest Good of all Netizens (utilitarianism) 3. International law based order and multilateralism 4. Respect towards sovereignty of nations involved
A right balance is needed between State interests and national sovereignty. However, citizen centricity is key to achieve aviation Safety norms.