While examining the shortcomings of the land reforms in the past, elaborate what land reforms 2.0 should look like.
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
Land reforms were undertaken post independence to provide land to the landless (~45%), enhance agricultural productivity and achieve social justice in alignment with Goals of Directive State Policies. However, these reforms are a partial success
Land reforms 1. Land Consolidation using cooperative farming 2. Abolition of Intermediaries 3. Reduce Concentration of wealth via Ceiling limits 4. Tenancy Reforms by giving land rights to tenant
Success of land reforms 1. Almost 100% success in Abolition of Intermediaries 2. States like Kerala, west Bengal achieved most objectives
Shortcomings of land reforms 1. Tenancy Reforms not fully successful due to varying definition of Tenant across states (eg) Sharecropper vs Tenant 2. land as part of state list, hence bottom up approach to be followed instead of top-down land reforms 3. Dominance of large landowners and Bureaucratic-Political nexus - (eg) Transfer of land to family to bypass ceiling limits 4. unorganised nature of tenancy, hence most of them not registered 5. Fragmentation of land holdings due to Increasing pressure on land, family disputes, Indebtedness (eg) Average size 1.08 ha 6. Rising Inequality as Bihar has land size as large as 1000 hectares whereas Mumbai - 0.008 hectares 7. lack of ownership rights to female (eg) less than 13% have land on their name - Economic Survey
Land reforms 2.0 1. Land Monetisation -> land as an asset using documentation (eg) DILRMP for modern land records 2. Land leasing to promote cultivation (eg) Kerala land leasing Policy makes Gram Panchayat party to Transaction (Economic Survey) 3. Joint Property Rights for women (eg) Maharashtra 4. Promotion of Cooperatives, FPO for reaping economies of scale 5. using emerging Technology (eg) Blockchain for land Records 6. Expedite implementation of SWAMITVA for conclusive Titling 7. Promotion of Contract farming
To boost agricultural productivity and transform Rural economy, land reforms 2.0 would play a key role in SDG 1, SDG 5 and SDG 10