In light of recent developments, the Collegium system and the Supreme Court's decision to strike down the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) Act, 2014 have once again come under scrutiny. Do you think that a NJAC-like body can make judicial appointments more transparent, broad-based, and accountable? Justify your answer.
Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025
Article 124 governs the appointment of judges in the Supreme court. It has been under constant debate.
Recent developments - Yashwant Verma Case -> Cash in the house - Appointment delays in SC & HC by govt. - Criticisms by retired judges as well as allegations of biasness by current judges
Evolution of Collegium [diagram: timeline of 1982, 1992, 1994, 2014 marked 1st judge case, 2nd judge case, 3rd judge case, NJAC case (IV)]
NJAC can make appointments
Transparent a. Ensure clear criterias for appointment b. Appointment based on merits rather than 'uncle judge' syndrome c. Tackle 'backdoor' affair criticism of collegium d. Based on majority votes -> no discrimination
Broad based a. NJAC consisting of varied members -> women, SC/ST etc -> inclusivity promotn b. Broad set of parameters for appointments, for holistic competency c. Publicised working & reasons ensure openess
Accountable a. Ensure merit based appointment & explanation for it b. Balance judiciary & executive interference in appointment c. Checks abuse of power by judiciary -> no imperio in imperum (Ambedkar) d. Checks & balances -> NJAC a better alternative to collegium
Issues a. Executive interference in judiciary -> undermine independence. b. Undue influence -> compromise autonomy of judges c. Can weaken judicial scrutiny & review of govt as judges might be chosen with a bias d. Seperation of power doctrine challenged e. Checks & balances might be harmed.
NJAC is a good initiative based on UK model