Topper Copies

Q.4) a) The interplay between laws and conscience is subtle; their synergy encourages ethical conduct, while dissonance can give rise to significant ethical dilemmas. Illustrate with examples.

Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025

Law and conscience both act as guiding light and aids in decision making despite differences in modes of mechanisms they work. Conscience is at individual level which law at societal.

Synergy between law and conscience

1. Both help in ethical decision making - Law amendments during Nirbhaya Case during collective conscience 2. Promotes social Justice and tries to find a balance - IAS name Armstrong built road using conscience and was legal 3. Helps resolve conflict of Interest and ethical dilemma - Abortion laws, labor laws

Dissonance between laws and conscience

1. In case of loopholes - Tax avoidance -> legal -> crisis of conscience 2. when laws made are unethical - Slavery laws during colonial -> legal -> cognitive dissonance 3. when laws donot exist at all - social media regulations -> cyberbullying, stalking 4. when laws donot follow procedural integrity - Farm laws 5. when collective conscience gets silenced due to group think - LGBTQ discrimination, Mob lynching, honor killing

Laws and conscience have their own limitations, they need to be converged with sea of ethics to minimise divergences.