Topper Copies

The principle of impartiality may conflict with the need for compassion towards marginalized communities. Discuss in the context of civil services in India.

Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025

Impartiality entails acting without Bias and Prejudices and is antithesis to Nepotism and favoritism - eg TN Seshan

Compassion entails desire to alleviate one's suffering and goes beyond empathy - eg Mother Teresa

There can be an apparent conflict between both values as -

1. Impartiality is value neutral and might overlook needs of most marginalised - eg Treating everyone alike 2. Compassion is value loaded and might cloud objective decision making due to influence of emotions - eg Civil servant hesitating to take anti-encroachment drive out of compassion

However, Both values go hand in Hand as -

1. Both uphold Rule of law - eg Impartiality is treating equals alike and unequals not alike → using constitutional morality to avert Bias and Prejudice against LGBTQ 2. Both leads to Good Governance - eg Nehru and Ambedkar despite having conflicts → Became part of constituent assembly (Impartiality) → Constitution as living document (outcome)

Ways to Balance

1. Using Emotional Intelligence to strive a Balance 2. Seeking help during dilemmas from Gandhi's talisman

Compassion and Impartiality are key foundational public service values and should be balanced to maximise social welfare and efficiency.