Discuss the implications of legalising MSP. What are the challenges involved, and what measures can improve its effectiveness?
Madhav Agarwal, AIR 16, 2024
MSP is the minimum price announced by government on recommendations of CACP for 22 crops before sowing season.
Recent farmer protests have brought legalisation of MSP to forefront which has both side of debate:-
Yes, MSP needed (legalization) 1. Government's failure to procure all crops, only rice-wheat majorly procured 2. Can help assure price to farmers when income is low: ₹10,218/month (NABARD) 3. Less than 6% know of MSP (NSSO survey) thus legalization can boost awareness 4. CACP in its report said legalization can help boost farmer confidence & production
However, it has roadblocks 1. Lead to high fiscal burden for state 2. Increase judicial cases = already lot of burden (4 crore case pending) 3. Maharashtra Case study: MSP was enforced but when prices dropped buyers withdrew from market -> huge loss. 4. NITI Aayog said price unsupported by demand and supply is not economically feasible. 5. Cannot solve issues like lack of forward & backward linkages. 6. Further reduce focus on capex and shift to revenue. 7. Inflation can increase (which is already high 9% in August 2023) (food inflation CPI)
Measures to make procurement effective 1. Decentralised procurement: by large states at their own level (Shanta Kumar Committee) 2. Promote PM-AASHA Model of boosting price difference, private procurement. 3. Crop diversification: shift away from rice-wheat to pulses, oilseeds, millets for WIN-WIN. 4. Bring mandi reforms: to make the procurement as per grading, weight. 5. Reduce populist measures: like MSP Bonuses. 6. Promotion to regulated and controlled "Contract farming"
MSP must be a medicine not a staple diet, which is also in interest of overall sector.