Examine the tension between the right to contest elections and the need to uphold electoral ethics under the Representation of the People Act. Should there be a lifetime ban on convicted criminals?
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
Representation of People Act (1951) was brought to enhance legal right to contest elections by stating Qualifications and disqualifications (as per constitutional mandate)
Right to Contest Elections 1. Fulfils Spirit of Republican democracy 2. Gives equal access to everyone 3. In alignment with Article 14 (Right to Equality)
Need to Uphold Electoral Ethics 1. Increasing criminalisation of Politics [bar chart: legislators facing criminal charges, 24% rising to 53% (ADR data)] 2. Rising use of Money and muscle Power (e.g.) more than 853% rise in money asset confiscations during elections since 2022-23 (ADR data) 3. Erodes Public Trust and Faith in democracy when law Breakers become law makers 4. Leads to voter apathy (stagnant turnout) 5. Low participation of youth in active Politics 6. Lacks Inner Party democracy as tickets given on 'winnability' criteria
Lifetime Ban on Convicted Criminals
Yes 1. Restores Public faith in democracy 2. Strong deterrence effect 3. Cleans up democracy
However, Permanent Ban could have below repercussions: 1. Rise in litigations against opposition -> Frivolous complaints -> further clogging of courts (4.5 crore cases pending) 2. Wrongful conviction of legislator 3. Against Reformative Justice and promotes Retaliatory Justice
Way Forward 1. Permanent Ban for severe cases (e.g. Rape, dowry and other sensitive cases) 2. Dedicated fast track courts to decide ban on advice of Election Commission of India (ECI) 3. Appeal mechanism to protect honest legislators 4. Reforms in Criminal Justice system
Long due electoral reforms like Cap on funding, audit of asset disclosure and Recommendations of Vohra committee is need of the hour to maintain right balance