The restrictions imposed under Article 293 of the Constitution on State borrowing powers, though constitutionally valid, may hinder fiscal autonomy of States and disrupt cooperative federalism. Discuss in the light of recent developments.
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
Article 293 of Constitution puts limits on Borrowing powers of the state by prohibiting States from borrowing from international institutions and seek approval from centre in case of outstanding liabilities
Rationale Behind Restrictions 1. To avoid Indiscriminate Borrowing by states -> Impact on national economy 2. To Inculcate fiscal discipline 3. Fixes financial accountability 4. Post-independence need of the hour due to limited resources with Centre
Constitutionally valid - Present Since original Constitution - India a Quasi federal State
Impact on Fiscal Autonomy of States 1. Restricts Borrowing powers needed for undertaking developmental needs 2. Assumes that Borrowing is Bad, an outdated philosophy as goes against Golden Rule of Borrowing 3. Funds needed during exigencies and provided during emergency relief amidst disasters (e.g.) Relief for Kerala landslides demanded exceptional funds
Impact on Cooperative Federalism 1. Goes against fiscal federalism as states are sovereign 2. Federalism as Basic doctrine under SR Bommai Case 3. Treats states as Subordinate due to clause of seeking approval 4. Allows centre to borrow from international market -> Greater powers to centre -> Centralising Tendencies
Way Forward 1. Expert committee to review the relevance of Article 293 2. Inter State council to decide on disruptions with respect to Borrowing capacities 3. State level legislation to comply with FRBM Act -> Fiscal accountability 4. Finance Commission Grants, Article 275 grants to meet exigencies
Though there is need for greater financial autonomy to states, there should be adequate safeguards to ensure debt sustainability amidst rising Revadi culture