Topper Copies

An eye for an eye only ends up making the whole world blind.

Shakti Dubey, AIR 1, 2024

"An eye for an eye will make the whole world blind."

When Gandhi launched the No-confidence motion (1921), there was great enthusiasm among the masses. As Gandhi held - "If NCM is properly implemented India would attain swaraj within a year". But to everyone's surprise Gandhi called back the movement post Chauri Chaura incident (1922). This led to criticism of Gandhi's decision from every section of society. To this Gandhi replied - "When you use voilence against violent repression by British, it gives them leverage to use greater force against us and this will create a viscious cycle of violence for violence creating more misery for all because - "An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind""

In this essay we explore various manifestation of "eye for an eye" in contemporary times and how it has lead to blurring of vision against humanity making the whole world blind. Along with this we will also see instances where and equal and opposite reaction becomes important in order to ensure a greater good.

Darkness cannot drive out darkness

Gandhi's entry into the Indian national movement is considered to be a watershed moment as it changed the entire course of action. We moved from prayer, petition and propaganda (Moderates) and extreamist activities towards Satyagrah.

Gandhi's idea of Satyagrah is based on Non-voilence (Ahimsa) and truth (Satya). Bipin Chandra in his book "India's Struggle for Independence" calls Gandhi as a spectacular mass leader. He advocated for "non-violence" as a strongest tool which ultimately led India to it's victory.

In hindsight if we see the question here is- "Did India have enough resources to fight British through violent means?" The answer was a no- and this would have led to more repression, masaccare and misery. Therefore Gandhi calls - Ahimsa as a tool of strong.

The entire concept of Satyagrah was based on the idea that - Violence should not be answered with violence instead with strategy and nonviolence as it will lead to loss for all. It's said- one of the biggest myth is that - "There are victors in war".

The perfect example for this is the world wars- that humanity has witnessed - Though it led Allied Powers to victory but the destruction caused to life and property- shall forever remain the biggest loss of humanity, because eye for an eye makes the whole world blind.

Turning blind eye

Post 9/11 attack USA launched - "War against terrorism" in 2001, which began from Afghanistan which was the epicentre for rising terrorism. USA used violent means to tackle the violence emnating from terrorism, and the results are before us. USA faced loss of life of several thousand soliders from 2001-2020- which ended with it's abrupt withdrawal from Afghanistan followed by takeover of Taliban in 2021.

Since then Afghanistan has been facing severe humanitarian crisis, human rights violation, increasing role of non-state actor in international politics, etc. The USA's decision of "Eye for an eye", has created an even more turbulent situation.

Malala, a young activist, states "Weapons can kill terrorist, but education can kill terrorism". This is what is supposed to be the right course of an action. The focus should not be on retaliating with greater force, rather the nations needs to focus on developmental process in Afghanistan to ensure a stable and safe society.

The recent humanitarian crisis in Gaza is also a manifestation of "An eye for an eye" - where Israel and Palestine, both have avoided the middle path of Dialouge and negotiation and have rather focussed on expansion & retaliation "making their whole world blind".

Winning hearts and mind

India today not only faces threat from hostile neighbours, but also internal security challenge in form of left wing extreamism (LWE). According to latest report by MHA, there have been 7100 deaths in last 5 years (2019-2023) because of LWE. The basic ideology guiding these extreamists is - violent overthrow of the existing system for which they have taken up arms against the government.

But Indian government instead of retaliating with greater force has focussed on the root cause of such discontent. IDSA report has highlighted that LWE is not a mere law and order problem, instead it is a issue arising from governance and developmental deficit.

To tackle this challenge government has come up with developmental schemes like Eklavya model residential Schools, Infrastructure development plans, setting up of geo tagged basic infrastructure like hospitals, etc. This is based on the idea that eye for an eye makes the whole world blind, so instead of retaliating with force we must focus on ensure overall regional development.

Such policies are more sensitive towards needs of people and are beneficial in long run leading to a stable internal security situation along with ensuring inclusive and sustainable development.

India has always abided by this principle, even during Mumbai Terror attack, 2008, when India suffered a severe blow because of terrorist attack. We managed to capture one of the convict, Ajmal Kasab, alive!! But instead of hanging him/punishing him straightaway, Indian Judiciary followed Due process of law which ultimately led to his execution in 2012 (4 years later). The principle remains the same, by hanging one convict we may kill a terrorist but not terrorism.

Reinforcement of strength

Though the idea of gandhi of "An eye for an eye" holds true for all circumstances but at certain situation we need to reinforce our strength to deter the adversaries. India's policy towards china post-Independence was based on the idea of "Hindi-Chini Bhai Bhai", this was very well evident when India offered it's permanent UNSC seat to china as an act of benovalence.

But today, it is China which keeps blocking India's entry into the UNSC as a permanent member. According to Bertin Linter in his book "China-India war", a new great game has begun in Asia between India and china in form of aggression at the borders, growing tensions in Indo-pacific and conflict between them to dominate smaller nations like Nepal, Bhutan, etc.

S. Jaishankar in his book "The India way" writes that though India upholds the principles of Panchsheel ie mutual non-aggression but India will never compromise with it's territorial integrity and sovereignity and India will engage with china from position of strength. This was visible during India's retaliation during Galwan clashes. Further India is trying to counterbalance China's aggressive rise through minilateral coalitions like QUAD. This is an example of pragmatism as the world is moving from Idealism towards realism.

Therefore at times we need to go for "eye for an eye" to deter the potential adversary and to ensure the greater good eg-: Saftey and security of it's citizen in this case.

Peace is always the middle path

Despite the evolution in world order and changing value system what remains constant is quest for peace. As it's said - "Threat to peace anywhere, is a threat to peace every where". Though violence yeild instant resent but peace can provide for a long lasting solution.

The world needs to abstain from any such act to ensure stability at international, national, community as well as individual level. As it's rightly said

"Darkness cannot drive out darkness only light can,

Hatred cannot drive out hatred only love can!!"