Topper Copies

The 103rd Constitutional Amendment Act, 2019 has introduced a new dimension to the principle of affirmative action in India. Critically examine its implications for the broader goal of social justice.

Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025

103rd Constitutional Amendment 2019 was adopted to uplift economically weaker sections of India by providing 10% reservations in public employment and educational Institutions. It was added to Article 15(4) and 16(4)

New Dimension to Principle of Affirmative Action 1. Historically, Social backwardness was taken as a criteria under Right to Equality. Hence, reservation based on Social status - SC, ST, OBC 2. A new dimension of backwardness i.e. Category with Income below Rs 8 lakh which goes beyond socio-political backwardness 3. In alignment with Constitutional morality as validated by Supreme court in Janhit Abhiyan case

Implications for Broader Goal of Social Justice 1. Meets true spirit of Preamble which entails social, political and economic justice 2. Interlinks economic disadvantage to social disadvantage (e.g.) Poverty as multi-dimensional concept 3. Definite criteria for availing reservation i.e. Income below Rs 8 lakh 4. Exemptions to exclude certain public offices to ensure targeted affirmative action

Issues with EWS 1. Blanket criteria of Rs 8 lakh lacks rationality and not based on evidence 2. Rising misuse and frauds of EWS category (e.g.) DoPT sends notice to 2023 civil servants for availing EWS 3. Economic Backwardness as natural progression of market economy and cannot be curtailed

Way Forward 1. Technology Integration for Robust validation of Income (e.g.) AI, ML to detect frauds 2. Dynamic criteria of Income based on Inflation 3. Gradual Phase down of Reservation in Viksit Bharat @2047

To meet the constitutional mandate of welfare state under Part IV, 103rd CA is a step in right direction; continuous evaluation is need of the hour to assess effectiveness