The Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act, 1958 (AFSPA) is necessary for maintaining peace and stability in the 'disturbed areas'. Critically examine.
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
AFSPA (Armed Forces Act 1958) was brought to enhance peace and security amidst rising insurgency and threats to national security post Independence.
Necessary for Peace and Stability 1. Provides immunity to police forces to act without fear or favor 2. Keeps control law and order situation during crisis like situation -> search and secure operations without warrant to avoid delays 3. Moral courage to armed forces and enhances self-defence -> Arrest and detain without warrant 4. Helps control insurgency with iron fist and decline in violence in north east prone areas 5. Creates confidence and trust among citizens, attracts investments, aids economic growth
Issues with AFSPA 1. Alleged violation of basic human rights 2. Recommendation by Justice Reddy Committee to repeal the act due to misuse of powers 3. Rape cases as highlighted by Justice Verma Committee
Way Forward 1. Immunity to forces not absolute but only to be used in emergency 2. Accountability mechanisms as fast track cases of rape 3. Oversight mechanism using civil society
AFSPA as a means to achieve peace and stability must be resorted with utmost care and empathy. After all, it is about winning hearts and minds of people