Topper Copies

The restrictions imposed under Article 293 of the Constitution on State borrowing powers, though constitutionally valid, may hinder fiscal autonomy of States and disrupt cooperative federalism. Discuss in the light of recent developments. (Answer in 250 words)

Simrandeep Kaur, AIR 15, 2025

Article 293 of Constitution limits borrowing powers of the state - limited to state's territory, on consolidated fund of state (collateral) and Centre's permission in case of pending debts.

Hindrance to fiscal autonomy

1. States as growth engines require foreign borrowings (eg) Gujarat from Japan. 2. Inter-State borrowings for regional balances (eg.) developed Kerala, T.N. to invest in Bihar, Madhya Pradesh. 3. Demand of removal of Centre's permission (T.N., Maharashtra). 4. (eg) Centre's State capex 50 year interest free loan may put them into perpetual Centre scrutiny.

Disruption to Cooperative federalism

1. Centre's undue interference violating principle of subsidiarity (2nd ARC) (eg) PM SHRI Punjab v/s Centre. 2. Perception of cultural mapping (eg) NEP and anti-Hindi chauvinism in south India. 3. Poor fiscal discipline if Centre is eroding fiscal autonomy (eg) NITI Aayog fiscal Health Index. 16%. Debt to GSDP in Punjab, West Bengal 4. Responsibility without fiscal powers e.g. SDG goals to be realized with more fiscal autonomy to the states.

Suggested balanced way

1. Constitutional amendment of Article 293 for more fiscal autonomy to states. 2. Foreign borrowings with RBI's facilitation 3. Apex body finance Commission (A.280) to promote more devolution to the states (41% in 15th FC). 4. Strengthening GST Council (A.279A) for Cooperative fiscal federalism.

The fiscal discipline under FRBM Act is necessary for sound health. Centre should stabilize macroeconomy and real allocation of values should be given to states as per principle of subsidiarity (2nd ARC).