The 103rd Constitutional Amendment Act, 2019 has introduced a new dimension to the principle of affirmative action in India. Critically examine its implications for the broader goal of social justice. (Answer in 250 words)
Simrandeep Kaur, AIR 15, 2025
103rd Constitutional Amendment Act, 2019 introduced Economically Weaker Section (EWS) based reservation - 10% in education and employment sections amending Article 15 and 16.
Implications on goal of social Justice
(A) Favourable
1. Poverty alleviation and inclusivity (eg) 11.28% of Indian population under Multi-dimensional Poverty (Niti Aayog). 2. Tailored approach of welfarism to downtrodden upper castes eg. Patidars, 3. Equity & social redistributive Justice.
[diagram: two boxes labelled "Equality" and "Equity", each with three stick figures standing on stacked crates of different heights - under Equality: "EWS, SC/ST, Rich with reservation"; under Equity: "EWS Reservation"]
4. fair representation of EWS in educational institutions -> breaking the vicious cycle of poverty. 5. fair allocation of public employment opportunities; addressing the economic backwardness.
(B) Challenges
1. Unfavourable competition to the un-reserved students & aspirants. 2. Reservation becoming permanent right and not just temporary social Justice policy. 3. Against the universal standard of meritocracy:- different benchmarks -> questions on credibility. 4. lack of empirical data:- Inclusion & Exclusion Challenges. 5. Reservation for socio-historical disadvantages is necessary for social mobility but EWS have scope of political expediency. 6. Rising demand of quota benefits eg. Jats, Marathas, Patidar. 7. Breaching limit of Indra Sawhney Judgement (less than 50%)
There is need of empirical data based, sunset-clause enabling and alternative Affirmative Action such as Skilling, Capacity building. It will empower all Jaatis of Viksit Bharat - Poor, farmer, youth & women.